-3
$\begingroup$

1

I don't know of any means to check my work, can anyone point out if they're any mistakes?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ It is prefered that you type things out rather than use an outside link. Text is searchable, and links may disappear. $\endgroup$ – Graham Kemp Nov 23 '18 at 3:27
0
$\begingroup$

Yes.   You are putting the deductions before their sub-proofs and the naming convention is not quite what I'm used to, but that looks okay.

To check, in my prefered format that would be:

$$\small\def\fitch#1#2{\quad\begin{array}{|l}#1\\\hline #2\end{array}}\fitch{1.~\lnot (p\to q)\qquad\textsf{Premise}}{\fitch{2.~\lnot(p\land\lnot q)\qquad\textsf{Assumption}}{3.~\lnot(p\to q)\qquad\textsf{Reiteration (1)}}\\4.~ \lnot(p\land\lnot q)\to\lnot(p\to q)\qquad\textsf{Conditional Introduction (2-3)}\\\fitch{5.~\lnot(p\land\lnot q)\qquad\textsf{Assumption}}{\fitch{6.~p\qquad\textsf{Assumption}}{\fitch{7.~\lnot q\qquad\textsf{Assumption}}{8.~p\land\lnot q\qquad\textsf{Conjunction Introduction (6,7)}}\\9.~\lnot q\to( p\land\lnot q)\qquad\textsf{Conditional Introduction (7-8)}\\\fitch{10.~\lnot q\qquad\textsf{Assumption}}{11.~\lnot (p\land\lnot q)\qquad\textsf{Reiteration (5)}}\\12.~\lnot q\to\lnot(p\land\lnot q)\qquad\textsf{Conditional Introduction (10-11)}\\13.~\lnot\lnot q\qquad\textsf{Negation Introduction (9,12)}\\14.~q\qquad\textsf{Double Negation Elimination (13)}}\\15.~p\to q\qquad\textsf{Conditional Introduction (6-14)}}\\16.~\lnot(p\land\lnot q)\to (p\to q)\qquad\textsf{Conditional Introduction (5-15)}\\17.~\lnot\lnot(p\land\lnot q)\qquad\textsf{Negation Introduction (4,16)}\\18.~p\land\lnot q\qquad\textsf{Double Negation Elimination (17)}\\\blacksquare}$$

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.