This might seem stupid, but I'm really stuck. I don't understand how to calculate the following explicitly:

$$\sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} \sum_{s_3=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}e^{-{s_2s_3}}$$

(it's the Ising model for 3 lattice sites).

I don't understand how I can calculate this in a brute force way, since the sums for $s_1$ and $s_3$ only apply to one part of the equation to be summed over.

(I know you can simplify it and end up with a much nicer expression in terms of cosh)

Help! Thanks.


Proceeding from right to left:

$$\begin{align*}\sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} \sum_{s_3=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}e^{-{s_2s_3}}& =\sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1}e^{-{s_1s_2}}\left[ e^{{s_2}}+e^{-{s_2}} \right]\\ &=\sum_{s_1=\pm1}\left( e^{{s_1}}\left[ e^{{-1}}+e^{1} \right]+e^{-{s_1}}\left[ e^{1}+e^{-{1}} \right]\right)\\ &=\sum_{s_1=\pm1}\left( [e^{{s_1}}+e^{-{s_1}}]\left[ e^{{-1}}+e^{1} \right]\right)\\ &=[e^{{-1}}+e^{1}]\left[ e^{{-1}}+e^{1} \right]+[e^{{1}}+e^{-1}]\left[ e^{{-1}}+e^{1} \right]\\ &=2[e^{{-1}}+e^{1}]^2\\ &=4(\cosh(2)+1) \end{align*}$$


A slightly alternate approach than in the other answer (dividing up the sum differently):

Starting with the inside sum of $$\sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} \sum_{s_3=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}e^{-{s_2s_3}},$$ we can factor out the term that doesn't depend on $s_3$ to get $$\sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} \sum_{s_3=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}e^{-{s_2s_3}}= \sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}\sum_{s_3=\pm1} e^{-{s_2s_3}}. $$ Now, let's look at the exponent of the internal sum, since $s_2$ is either $+1$ or $-1$, then $-s_2$ is either $+1$ or $-1$. Multiplying by $s_3$ which is either $+1$ or $-1$ results in one of each of $+1$ and $-1$. Therefore, the sum simplifies to $$ \sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}\sum_{s_3=\pm1} e^{-{s_2s_3}}= \sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}(e+e^{-1})=(e+e^{-1})\sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}. $$ By applying the same argument as above, we see that the exponent of this $e$ is one of each of $+1$ and $-1$, so we get $$ (e+e^{-1})\sum_{s_1=\pm1} \sum_{s_2=\pm1} e^{-{s_1s_2}}=(e+e^{-1})\sum_{s_1=\pm1} (e+e^{-1})=(e+e^{-1})^2\sum_{s_1=\pm1}1. $$ Since there are only two values for $s_1$, we get that this simplifies to $2(e+e^{-1})^2$, which can then be simplified in terms of $\cosh$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.