We're given a triangle $ABC$.

Going clockwise, let $B_1$ and $B_2$ be distinct points on the segment $AC$ ($B_1$ is between $A$ and $B_2$), let $A_1$ and $A_2$ be distinct points on the segment $CB$ ($A_1$ is between $C$ and $A_2$), and finally let $C_1$ and $C_2$ be distinct points on the segment $AB$ ($C_1$ is between $B$ and $C_2$).

The circumcircles of triangles $CB_1A_1$ and $CB_2A_2$ intersect at $C_3 \neq C$.

The circumcircles of triangles $BA_1C_1$ and $BA_2C_2$ intersect at $B_3 \neq B$.

The circumcircles of triangles $AB_1C_1$ and $AB_2C_2$ intersect at $A_3 \neq A$.

Prove that the lines $AA_3$, $BB_3$ and $CC_3$ have a common point.

  • $\begingroup$ I hid the history of this problem with the hope of trying to get more people to attempt a solution (using high-school math material only) $\endgroup$ – Meina222 Feb 11 '13 at 15:56

Consider the region near vertex $A$. (Point $B$ on ray $AC_2$ and point $C$ on ray $AB_1$ not pictured.)

Cyclic Quadrilateral AB1A3C1 Cyclic Quadrilateral AB2A3C2

$\square AB_1A_3C_1$ is cyclic, so opposite angles $\angle B_1$ and $\angle C_1$ are supplementary; consequently, $\angle B_1 \cong \angle A_3 C_1 C_2$ (the latter itself being a supplement of $\angle C_1$). Likewise, $\angle C_2 \cong \angle A_3 B_2 B_1$.

Similar Triangles A3B1B2 and A3C1C2

By the Angle-Angle Similarity Theorem, we have that $\triangle A_3 B_1 B_2 \sim \triangle A_3 C_1 C_2$, and we deduce that the "bases" ($B_1B_2$ and $C_1C_2$) and corresponding "altitudes" ($A_3P$ and $A_3Q$) of these triangles have proportional lengths; but note that those altitudes are directly related to the angles into which $\angle A$ has been divided. Therefore,

$$\frac{|B_1B_2|}{|C_1C_2|} = \frac{|A_3P|}{|A_3Q|} = \frac{|AA_3|\sin\angle A_3AB_1}{|AA_3|\sin\angle A_3AC_2} = \frac{\sin\angle A_3AC}{\sin\angle A_3AB}$$

Likewise for vertex $B$ and vertex $C$, so that the trigonometric form of Ceva's Theorem is satisfied:

$$ \frac{\sin\angle A_3AC}{\sin\angle A_3AB} \; \frac{\sin\angle B_3BA}{\sin\angle B_3BC} \; \frac{\sin\angle C_3CB}{\sin\angle C_3CA} \; = \; \frac{|B_1B_2|}{|C_1C_2|} \; \frac{|C_1C_2|}{|A_1A_2|} \; \frac{|A_1A_2|}{|B_1B_2|} \; = \; 1$$

proving that the lines $AA_3$, $BB_3$, $CC_3$ share a common point.

  • $\begingroup$ Awesome! This is slightly different than my original idea, but in the end it does go to Ceva's theorem. $\endgroup$ – Meina222 Feb 12 '13 at 17:15
  • $\begingroup$ Added my original solution. Thumbs up for the less algebraic one found by Blue. $\endgroup$ – Meina222 Feb 12 '13 at 19:30

Here's my original solution when creating the problem.

Focus on vertex $C$. Let $CC_3$ intersect $AB$ at $C_4$ (one can show $C_4$ is between $A$ and $B$).


$|BC_4|\vec{CA} + |AC_4|\vec{CB} = (|AC_4|+|BC_4|)\vec{CC_4} = |AB|\vec{CC_4}$

since $C_4$ is the center of mass of $A$ and $B$ with weights $|BC_4|$ and $|AC_4|$ respectively.

If you multiply both sides by the the diameter vector incident at $C$ of $CA_1B_1$'s circumcircle, and simplify by removing the cosines, you get:

$|BC_4||CA||CB_1| + |AC_4||CB||CA_1| = |AB||CC_4||CC_3|$


$|BC_4||CA||CB_2| + |AC_4||CB||CA_2| = |AB||CC_4||CC_3|$


$|BC_4||CA||CB_1| + |AC_4||CB||CA_1| = |BC_4||CA||CB_2| + |AC_4||CB||CA_2|$

Rewrite above as:

$\frac{(|CB_1|-|CB_2|)|CA|}{(|CA_2|-|CA_1|)|CB|} = \frac{|AC_4|}{|BC_4|}$

which yields (from the way points are ordered):

$\frac{|B_1B_2||CA|}{|A_1A_2||CB|} = \frac{|AC_4|}{|BC_4|}$

If we define $B_4$ and $A_4$ in similar fashion, the same reasoning yields:

$\frac{|C_1C_2||AB|}{|B_1B_2||CA|} = \frac{|BA_4|}{|CA_4|}$

$\frac{|A_1A_2||CB|}{|C_1C_2||AB|} = \frac{|CB_4|}{|AB_4|}$

From the last 3 identities, we conclude:

$\frac{|AC_4|}{|BC_4|}\frac{|BA_4|}{|CA_4|}\frac{|CB_4|}{|AB_4|} = \frac{|B_1B_2||CA|}{|A_1A_2||CB|}\frac{|C_1C_2||AB|}{|B_1B_2||CA|}\frac{|A_1A_2||CB|}{|C_1C_2||AB|} = 1$

By Ceva's theorem it follows that $AA_4, BB_4, CC_4$ have a common point.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.