-1
$\begingroup$

Given the definition for any real numbers a and b, the max function is

$\max\{a, b\} = \begin{cases} a \text{ if } a \geq b \\ b \text{ if } a < b \\ \end{cases} $

Lemma: for any two real numbers $a\text{ and }b, a \leq \max\{a,b\}$ and $ b \leq \max\{a,b\}$.

Prove that for real numbers, $a, b$, and $x$, if a $\leq x \leq$ b then $|x| \leq \max\{|a|,|b|\}$.

So far, I have

$x \geq 0$ or $x < 0$ by the law of trichotomy

Case 1: $x\geq 0$

$|x| = x$ by the definition of absolute value

and I'm not sure where to go from there. Any hints?

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

Hints Through a Conversation

I'm going to restate your lemma to make it simpler, so you can see later how this lemma is applicable to your problem.

Lemma. For all real numbers $\alpha$ and $\beta$ $$\alpha \leq \max\big(\alpha, \beta\big)$$

We don't need to state $\beta \leq \max\big(\alpha,\beta\big)$, because if the above lemma is true for all $\alpha$, then it is true for all $\beta$; that is $\beta \leq \max\big(\alpha,\beta\big)$.

Observation

Next we need to observe the rather trivial inequality $|\alpha| \leq |\alpha|$. Obviously, they are equal, but it will be more useful at the moment to right it as an inequality, because, by the definition of absolute value, we obtain $$-|\alpha| \leq \alpha \leq |\alpha|$$ You can use this in your proof by saying something like "Since $|b| \leq |b|$ we have $-|b| \leq b \leq |b|$ by definition of absolute value." This is a valid move, because we are only using the definition of the absolute value and the trivial inequality $|b|\leq|b|$.

Now, notice that by definition of the absolute value, the inequality $|x|\leq\max\big(|a|,|b|\big)$ is equivalent to $$-\max\big(|a|,|b|\big)\leq x \leq \max\big(|a|,|b|\big)$$

Let's focus on the right inequality $x \leq \max\big(|a|,|b|\big)$. From the above lemma if we set $\alpha = |b|$ and $\beta = |a|$, then we get $$|b| \leq \max\big(|a|, |b|\big)$$ What remains to be shown is that $x \leq |b|$. Can you use our observation to establish the right inequality?

You now have enough information to work on a proof. I have provided my proof but concealed it. Hover over the yellowish area with your mouse to reveal my solution.

Proof

Let $a,b$ and $x$ denote real numbers such that $a \leq x \leq b$. Since $b \leq |b|$ we have $$x \leq b \leq |b| \leq \max\big(|a|,|b|\big)$$ Further $-\max\big(|a|, |b|\big) \leq -|a| \leq a$, so we deduce $$-\max\big(|a|, |b|\big) \leq -|a| \leq a \leq x \leq b \leq |b| \leq \max\big(|a|, |b|\big)$$ or $$-\max\big(|a|, |b| \big) \leq x \leq \max\big(|a|, |b|\big)$$ Therefore $$|x| \leq \max\big(|a|, |b|\big)$$

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.