I worked my way to encounter a system of equations

\begin{equation} \begin{cases} q=k_1\cos\phi_1+k_2\cos\phi_2& \\ 0=k_1\sin\phi_1+k_2\sin\phi_2& \end{cases} \end{equation}

I don't need to solve for specific angles $\phi_1,\phi_2$ because these equations will probably be very rough, but it's enough to know the answer in terms of $\cos\phi_1$ and $\sin\phi_2$ or vice versa. If I am looking to solve this by hand then what I have to do is obviously rewrite one of the trigonometric functions in terms of the other, for example

\begin{equation} \begin{cases} q=k_1\cos\phi_1\pm k_2\sqrt{1-\sin^2\phi_2}& \\ 0=\pm k_1\sqrt{1-\cos^2\phi_1}+k_2\sin\phi_2& \end{cases}, \end{equation} where now it's just basic algebra to solve the equations.

My question concerns the $\pm$ signs that appear there. I can rearrange the equations in such a way, that after squaring them I get a sign independent result again. Hence I get a unique solution to this equation. But to me that seems weird - I would assume I should get solutions that aren't unique. I assume that I must at some point arrive at some expression that differs by (at least) a sign, since I am expressing everything in terms of $\cos\phi_1$ and $\sin\phi_2$, which can swap signs depending on their argument. Could anyone clear this up for me?


Let me reframe this for a bit...also let's assume $\phi_1$ and $\phi_2$ are "interesting" (not $0, \pi$, etc).

Just to be on the same page, let's solve the equation first. Isolating the square roots in both equations gives $q - k_1 \cos\phi_1 = \pm k_2 \sqrt{1-\sin^2 \phi_2}$ and $\mp k_1 \sqrt{1 - \cos^2 \phi_1} = k_2^2 \sin^2 \phi_2$. Squaring and solving gives

$$ \cos \phi_1 = \frac{q^2 + k_1^2 - k_2^2}{2qk_1} $$

which is indeed sign independent. But all of the terms with $\sin \phi_2$ are squared, so $\sin \phi_2$ is not sign independent. Solving the other way, that is, writing $q - k_2 \cos\phi_2 = \pm k_1 \sqrt{1-\sin^2 \phi_1}$ and $\mp k_2 \sqrt{1 - \cos^2 \phi_2} = k_1^2 \sin^2 \phi_1$, gives

$$ \cos \phi_2 = \frac{q^2 + k_2^2 - k_1^2}{2qk_2} $$

(which also makes sense because of symmetry). Similarly, you can't get a value for $\sin \phi_1$ here, since all the $\sin \phi_1$ terms are squared.

The first time, $\cos \phi_1$ was sign-independent and $\sin \phi_2$ wasn't. The second time, $\cos \phi_2$ was sign independent and $\sin \phi_1$ wasn't. Specifically, if you try to solve for the $\sin$s, you get expressions like $\sin \phi = \pm \text{(stuff)}$.

Think of the unit circle for a second. Geometrically, we know the x-coordinates of $\phi_1$ and $\phi_2$, but not their y-coordinates. Though we do know the two possible candidates are $\pm$ of each other. So we are almost done but not quite. We have four possible solutions: $(\phi_1, \phi_2)$, $(\phi_1, -\phi_2)$, $(-\phi_1, \phi_2)$, $(-\phi_1, -\phi_2)$.

Note that $(\phi_1, \phi_2)$ if a solution if and only if $(-\phi_1, -\phi_2)$ is, and the same holds for the two other solution candidates $(\phi_1, -\phi_2)$, $(-\phi_1, \phi_2)$. (See this by plugging them into the second equation.) And $(\phi_1, \phi_2)$ and $(\phi_1, -\phi_2)$ can't both be solutions because the second equation would give $\sin \phi_1 = 0$, a contradiction. Since $(\phi_1, \phi_2)$ is of course a solution to the equation, this tells you that the only two solutions of the equation are $(\phi_1, \phi_2)$ and $(-\phi_1, -\phi_2)$.

This is a long-winded way of saying: You do get solutions that aren't unique when solving this. Specifically, you get 4 solutions, and 2 of them turn out to be fake solutions, leaving you with 2 actual ones. I can't tell where exactly in your question you went wrong, because you didn't explain your solution path, but hopefully this clears things up.

  • $\begingroup$ Yeah, your explanation makes sense. I didn't give too much information, since I actually wanted to solve this one on my own (it's not that hard after all). I'll try to apply this to my problem. Thanks. $\endgroup$ – Henrikas Aug 16 '18 at 8:13

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.