$\newcommand{\Cof}{\operatorname{cof}} \newcommand{\id}{\operatorname{Id}}$ Let $V$ be a real $d$-dimensional vector space ($d>2$). Let $2 \le k \le d-1$ be fixed, and let $r>k$.

Define $H_r=\{ A \in \text{End}(V) \mid \operatorname{rank}(A) = r \}$. $H_r$ is a submanifold of $ \text{End}(V)$.

Consider the map $$\psi:H_r \to \text{End}(\bigwedge^{k}V) \, \,, \, \, \psi(A)=\bigwedge^{k}A,$$

where $\bigwedge^{k} V$ is the $k$-th exterior power of $V$.

Denote $\tilde H_s=\{ B \in \text{End}(\bigwedge^kV) \mid \operatorname{rank}(B) = s \}$, and note that for $A \in \text{End}(V)$,
$$\operatorname{rank}(\bigwedge^kA) = \binom {\operatorname{rank}(A)}{k} ,$$ that is $\psi(H_r) \subseteq \tilde H_{\binom {r}{k}}$

Is $\psi(H_r)$ a closed subset of $ \tilde H_{\binom {r}{k}}$? (The topology on $ \tilde H_{\binom {r}{k}}$ is the subspace topology induced by $\text{End}(\bigwedge^kV)$).

Comment: In the special case where $r=d$ the answer is positive; we have $H_d=\text{GL}(V)$ and $ \tilde H_{\binom {d}{k}}=\text{GL}(\bigwedge^{k}V)$, and $\psi(\text{GL}(V))$ is closed in $\text{GL}(\bigwedge^{k}V)$.


The answer is positive, since $\psi:H_r \to \tilde H_{\binom {r}{k}}$ is proper, and every proper map is closed.

Here is a proof $\psi$ is proper:

Let $K \subseteq \tilde H_{\binom {r}{k}}$ be compact, and let $A_n \in \psi^{-1}(K)$. We shall prove $A_n$ has a convergent subsequence in $\psi^{-1}(K)$. It suffices to prove $A_n$ converges in $\text{End}(V)$; indeed, if $A_n \to A$, then $\bigwedge^k A_n \to \bigwedge^k A$, and the limit $\bigwedge^k A$ must be in $K$. In particular, $\binom {r}{k}=\operatorname{rank}(\bigwedge^kA) = \binom {\operatorname{rank}(A)}{k}$, so $\operatorname{rank}(A)=r$, that is $A \in H_r$.

By using SVD, we can assume $A_n=\text{diag}(\sigma_1^n,\dots,\sigma_r^n,0,\dots,0)$ is diagonal, where the first $r$ diagonal elements are non-zero, and the last $d-r$ elements are zero. (Since the orthogonal group is compact, the isometric components surely converge after passing to a subsequence).

$\bigwedge^k A_n$ is diagonal, and its first $\binom {r}{k}$ elements are of the form $\Pi_{s=1}^k \sigma_{i_s}^n$, where all the $1 \le i_s \le r$ are distinct. So, every such product converges when $n \to \infty$ to a positive number. Indeed, $\psi(A_n)=\bigwedge^k A_n \in K \subseteq \tilde H_{\binom {r}{k}}$, so it converges (after passing to a subsequence) to an element $D \in K$. Since $\text{rank}(D)=\binom {r}{k}$, it follows that the products $\Pi_{s=1}^k \sigma_{i_s}^n$ must converge to positive numbers. (If even one of them converges to zero instead, the rank of the limit $D$ would be too low, which is a contradiction).

Now, let $1\le i \neq j \le r$. Since $r \ge k+1$, we can choose some $1 \le i_1,\dots,i_{k-1} \le r$ all different from $i,j$. Since both products $$(\Pi_{s=1}^{k-1} \sigma_{i_s}^n)\sigma_{i}^n,(\Pi_{s=1}^{k-1} \sigma_{i_s}^n)\sigma_{j}^n$$ converge to positive numbers, so does their ratio $C_{ij}^n=\frac{\sigma_i^n}{\sigma_j^n}$.

We know that $$\Pi_{s=1}^k \sigma_{s}^n=\Pi_{s=1}^k \sigma_{1}^n\frac{\sigma_s^n}{\sigma_1^n}=\Pi_{s=1}^k \sigma_{1}^nC_{s1}^n=(\sigma_{1}^n)^k \Pi_{s=1}^k C_{s1}^n$$ converges to a positive number. Since all the $C_{s1}^n$ converge to positive numbers, we deduce $\sigma_1^n$ converges. W.L.O.G the same holds for every $\sigma_i^n$, so $A_n$ indeed converges. (and we know the limit must have the right rank).


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.