7
$\begingroup$

A family has two children. Given that at least one of the children is a boy who was born on a Tuesday, what is the probability that both children are boys?

The day of birth is independent of the gender

P(both are boys $\mid $ at least one boy) = P(both are boys) / P(at least one boy)

$= P(\text {both are boys}) / [1 - P(\text{both are girls}$)]

$= 0.5^2/(1-0.5^2)$

$= 0.25/0.75$

$= 0.3333$

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ You calculation is so weird (look at the fourth equality). And where does $0.52$ come from? $\endgroup$ – Zhanxiong May 13 '18 at 21:08
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ it is a typo I guess, i.e. 0.25 $\endgroup$ – user519338 May 13 '18 at 21:09
  • $\begingroup$ See this question for insight $\endgroup$ – Namaste May 13 '18 at 21:26
  • $\begingroup$ The gender of a child is independent of its day of birth, but that is not enough to conclude that you can ignore the "... born on a Tuesday" part of the given information in the conditional probability. $\endgroup$ – Excluded and Offended May 13 '18 at 21:29
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ See this blog post for a very readable treatment of this question and variations. $\endgroup$ – Alex Riley May 13 '18 at 21:30
6
$\begingroup$

Have a look and count the number of succesful outcomes compared to the total number:

enter image description here

If you correct for biological factors, however, the answer may be skewed in either direction. Perhaps boys are a little more likely than girls, so I have heard.


If we only dealt with gender, not the day of week, your figure would have been correct since the table would then simply be:

enter image description here


The two things that confuse our intuitions are:

  1. It is counter intuitive that someone would NOT mention which kid (the oldest, the youngest) which allows for the overlapping areas in the two tables.

  2. It is counter intuitive that the day of week plays the role that it does.

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

This is another twist on the classic Boy or Girl paradox (Wikipedia). This variant even has its own section on the Wikipedia page.

You do have to include the information about Tuesday. Let $A$ be the event both children are boys, and let $B$ be the event at least one was a Boy born on a Tuesday.

$$ P(A|B)=\frac{P(A\cap B)}{P(B)}=\frac{(1/2)^2\cdot (1-(6/7)^2)}{1-(1-(1/2)(1/7))^2}\neq \frac13 $$

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

It depends on how the "given" information is determined:

  1. You say "Gee, Mr. Smith, I hear you have two children. Is either, or both, perhaps a boy who was born on a Tuesday?" Mr. Smith replies "That's an odd question. The chances are only 27/196 that you would have guessed right, but in this case you did. At least one of my children is a boy who was born on a Tuesday."

  2. You say "Gee, Mr. Jones, I hear you have two children. Can you tell me an odd fact that applies to at least one of them?" Mr. Jones replies "Well, at least one is a boy who was born on a Tuesday."

The answer in case #1 is 13/27. There are 196 possible combinations of day+gender in a two-child family. 27 of those include Tuesday Boy, and 13 of those have two boys.

The answer in case #2 is 1/2, because Mr. Jones could have told you about, say, a girl who was born on a Thursday when he also had a boy who was born on a Tuesday. In fact, of the 27 combinations, 26 include a different form of the day+gender description. If you didn't ask about Tuesday Boys, you can only assume Mr. Jones would choose randomly between the two. So you have to dismiss 13 cases where he has a Tuesday Boy, including 6 where he has two. The answer is (13-6)/(27-13)=7/14=1/2.

What seems to perplex far too many people, is that the requirement that we know "one is a boy who was born on a Tuesday" is not the same event as the observation about one child, that he "is a boy who was born on a Tuesday."

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

The original question is incomplete, since it does not state the experiment conducted in arriving at the facts in the problem description.

In probability theory, probability spaces are used to model experiments in the real world. However, in this case, we discern no such model or experiment; hence the question is incomplete.

We could just as well have stated the question as:

"A family has two children of which one is a boy born on a Tuesday; what is the probability both children are boys?"

to which the answer could be 13/27.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.