Does there exist a counter-example to the following claim:

For a function $f: \mathbb{R}^2 \to \mathbb{R}$, if:

$D_1f$ exists in some ball around the origin and is continuous at the origin (but not necessarily anywhere else)

$D_2f$ exists at the origin (but not necessarily anywhere else)

then $f$ is differentiable at the origin.

I know that if we add either the condition "$D_2f$ is continuous at the origin" or "$D_1f$ is continuous in the open ball around the origin" then $f$ must be differentiable at the origin, but I can't find a non-differentiable function just satisfying the above two properties.


There is no counterexample, and we can further weaken things by not requiring $D_1 f$ to exist on the $y$-axis, and we don't even need $f$ to be required to be continuous anywhere on the $y$-axis with origin removed (note that neither one implies the other).

We can assume WLOG $f,D_1f,D_2f$ are $0$ at the origin by subtracting off the function $f(0)+Df(O)(x,y)$.

Then for $h=(h_1,h_2)$ in a small punctured disc around $O$, $\frac{f(h_1,h_2)}{\sqrt{h_1^2+h_2^2}}=\frac{f(h_1,h_2)-f(0,h_2)}{\sqrt{h_1^2+h_2^2}}+\frac{f(0,h_2)}{\sqrt{h_1^2+h_2^2}}=g(h_1,h_2)\frac{h_1}{\sqrt{h_1^2+h_2^2}}+r(h_2)\frac{h_2}{\sqrt{h_1^2+h_2^2}}$


$g(h_1,h_2)=\frac{f(h_1,h_2)-f(0,h_2)}{h_1}$ when $h_1 \ne 0$, otherwise $0$

$r(h_2)=\frac{f(0,h_2)}{h_2}$ when $h_2 \ne 0$, otherwise $0$.

(no continuity was used here, this is always true).

For $h_1 \ne 0$, $g(h_1,h_2)=D_1(\epsilon(h_1,h_2) h_1,h_2)$ for some $0<\epsilon(h_1,h_2)<1$ which is a function of $h_1,h_2$ by mean value theorem.

Thus in any case, $|g| \le D_1(\epsilon(h_1,h_2) h_1,h_2) \to 0$, so since $|\frac{h_1}{\sqrt{h_1^2+h_2^2}}| \le 1$, the first term goes to $0$.

By definition of $Df_2$, $r$ is continuous at $0$, so $r(h_2) \to 0$ as $(h_1,h_2) \to 0$. Since $|\frac{h_2}{\sqrt{h_1^2+h_2^2}}| \le 1$, the second term goes to $0$.

Thus $\frac{f(h_1,h_2)}{\sqrt{h_1^2+h_2^2}} \to 0$, so $f$ is diff. at $0$, and we're done.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.