I am trying to define a probabilistic model for an experiment involving the following steps:

  1. Choose at random 1 dice from a bag containing 5 die (1 each of 4 sided, 6 sided 8 sided 12 sided and 20 sided)
  2. Roll chosen die once
  3. Observe the outcome.

So far, I've come up with 2 models through which probabilities can be assigned to the outcomes. Each model assigns a different probability value to each outcome.

The first method:

I assign equal probabilities to each trial. Then, I assign probabilities to outcomes by summing over trials.

Example: Probability that outcome is 1 = $\frac{5}{50}$= 0.1

(Here I assume that the sample space is composed of 4+6+8+12+20=50 equally likely outcomes and the number of favorable outcomes is 5)

The second method:

I assign probabilities to outcomes assuming that a given outcome is a succession of two 'sub'-outcomes- "choosing a die" and "rolling it once". I treat these 'sub'-outcomes as independent and calculate probability based on this assumption.

Example:Probability that outcome is 1 = $\frac{1}{5}$$\frac{1}{4}$+$\frac{1}{5}$$\frac{1}{6}$+$\frac{1}{5}$$\frac{1}{8}$+$\frac{1}{5}$$\frac{1}{12}$+$\frac{1}{5}$$\frac{1}{20}$ = 0.135

(Here I assume that the probability of choosing any one of the five dice is $\frac{1}{5}$; and having chosen a given die, the probability of outcome being 1 is $\frac{1}{4}$ for die with 4 sides, $\frac{1}{6}$ for die with 6 sides and so on)

Which method is correct?

Summing probabilities over all outcomes in both cases gives 1.

Using method 1:






Using method 2:






  • $\begingroup$ Using Baye's conditional probability, P(1) = P(1|4 sided die chosen) + P(1|6 sided die chosen) + P(1|8 sided die chosen) + P(1|12 sided die chosen) + P(1|20 sided die chosen) = $\frac{1}{4}$+$\frac{1}{6}$+$\frac{1}{8}$+$\frac{1}{12}$+$\frac{1}{20}$ = 0.675. I cannot understand how the weight $\frac{1}{5}$ comes into play here; unless the premise is flawed. In which case, how? $\endgroup$
    – Rob Plant
    Apr 27, 2018 at 3:45

1 Answer 1


The second method is correct. In the first method, assigning each possibility of "occurrence of 1" equal probability would mean that you'd have the same chances to get 1 from a 6 faced and a 20 faced die. But you know the probability of getting 1 from a 20 faced die would obviously be less. That's one way of looking at it. Hope it helps.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .