enter image description here

My solution for the third problem is, compute the CDF with Law of Total Probability,

$\begin{align}F_{Y}(y) &= P[Y\leq y] = P[g(x)\leq y] \\ &=P[g(x)\leq y \mid x\in(1,2]]P[x\in(1,2]] + P[g(x)\leq y \mid x\in(2,4]]P[x\in(2,4]] \\ &= P[2x-1\leq y]P[x\in(1,2]] + P[5-x\leq y]P[x\in(2,4]]\end{align}$.

Then the PDF,

$f_{Y}(y) = \displaystyle\frac{d}{dy}F_{Y}(y)$.

But this solution turns out incorrect.

Can someone help me to point out the error?

  • $\begingroup$ One qustion: Isn´t $P(Y=1)=0$, since $Y$ is a continuous variable? $\endgroup$ – callculus Apr 23 '18 at 18:33

The error is that what you wrote is not a cdf. You cut the tail of the distribution $Y<1$ but you forgot to rescale it with Bayes formula. $$F_{Z}(y) = P[Y\leq y | Y>1] = \dfrac{P[Y\leq y \cap Y>1]}{P[Y>1]} = \dfrac{P[2x-1\leq y]P[x\in(1,2]] + P[5-x\leq y]P[x\in(2,4]]}{P[x\in(1,4]]}$$.

I believe you already used that scaling property to solve question 1) for example.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.