$x + y + z = 4$
$x^2 + y^2 + z^2 = 4$
$x^3 + y^3 + z^3 = 4$

Any ideas on how to solve for $(x,y,z)$ satisfying the three simultaneous equations, provided there can be both real and complex solutions?


For a fixed number of variables and a fixed power $n$ the sum of powers $$x^n + y^n + z^n + ... + w^n$$ is a symmetric polynomial.

It is expressible in terms of elementary symmetric polynomials. The elementary symmetric polynomials for three variables are

  • $e_1 = x + y + z$
  • $e_2 = x y + x z + y z$
  • $e_3 = x y z$

and your polynomials expressed in terms of them are

  • $x + y + z = e_1$
  • $x^2 + y^2 + z^2 = e_1^2 - 2 e_2$
  • $x^3 + y^3 + z^3 = e_1^3 - 3(e_1 e_2 - e_3)$

Now we can find the values of $e_1,e_2,e_3$ evaluated at the given $x,y,z$:

$e_1 = 4$, $e_2 = 6$, $e_3 = 4$.

Now consider the polynomial $(t - x)(t - y)(t - z) = t^3 - e_1 t^2 + e_2 t - e_3 = t^3 - 4 t^2 + 6 t - 4$.

It has the solutions $t = 2, 1 + i$ and $1 - i$.

So now we can check if these are correct:

  • $(2) + (1+i) + (1-i) = 4$
  • $(2)^2 + (1+i)^2 + (1-i)^2 = 4 + 2i - 2i = 4$
  • $(2)^3 + (1+i)^3 + (1-i)^3 = 8 + -2 + 2i -2 - 2i = 4$

You can write the elementary functions in terms of these sums of powers, thus getting the coefficients for a polynomial equation whose roots are $x$, $y$, and $z$. For instance, squaring the first equation and subtracting the second, you get the value of $xy+yz+xz$. Cubing the first equation and using what you now know, you get the value of $xyz$. In general you can use Newton's identities.


If you just want an answer, Wolfram Alpha makes short work of it, producing $(2,1+i,1-i)$ and all permutations of that. You expect six solutions from the product of the degrees. You can easily try x=y=z and y=z and find a contradiction, proving that the values of x,y, and z are all distinct. Then there is really only one solution, with permutations giving the six. If the solution is real, substitution will yield a sixth degree polynomial. If the solution is not all real, you must have one real value and two conjugate complex values, so set $y=a+bi, z=a-bi$ with $x, a$ and $b$ real. This gives

$\begin{align} &x+2a=4 \\ &x^2+2a^2-2b^2=4 \\ &x^3+2a^3-6ab^2=4 \end{align}$

which is actually easier than the real version. You can solve the second for $b^2$, insert it into the third along with $x=4-2a$ and get a cubic that will have $a=1$ as a solution.

I tried playing with the symmetric polynomials, but didn't find any slick approach.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.