Computer output:

Test of mu = 77 versus mu not = 77 Variable N Mean StDev malt extract 40 77.458 1.101 Variable 95.0% Conf. Int. Z P-value malt extract ( 77.116, 77.799) 2.63 0.009

Problem: Use the value for $Z$ to test the null hypothesis $H_0$ : m $\leq$ 77.0 versus the one-sided alternative $H_1$ : m > 77.0 at the $\alpha=.05$ level of significance.

My attempt: The $Z$ statistic will not change, so we should calculate $z_{\alpha}$ and see whether $Z<z_{\alpha}$ or $Z>z_{\alpha}$. $z_{\alpha}=\Phi^{-1}(1-0.05)=1.645$. Since $Z>z_{\alpha}$ we reject $H_0$. However, decision based on the p-value should give the same result, right? The one-tailed p-value is $0.009/2=0.0045$, which is less than $\alpha=0.05$, so we fail to reject $H_0$. What am I missing?


1 Answer 1


The p-value in a hypothesis test tells you the probability that $Z>z^*$ where $z^*$ is the test statistic. So if the p-value is less than the confidence level, we reject $H_0$ in favor of $H_1$, the same result obtained by the critical region process. I think you have just confused the decision rule.

A smaller p-value means a higher significance because it indicates that the hypothesis may not explain the observation enough.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .