I am in Calculus II and this is one of our exercises for integration:

$$\int x(x+3)^{-1/2} dx$$

This looked to me like a sober example of when to use Integration By Parts, so I went with that:

$$u = x$$

From which I got the $$du = dx$$

Then I took $$dv = (x+3)^{-1/2}$$

And found $$v=2\sqrt{x+3}$$ using a simple substitution.

I then proceeded with the formula $$\int{f(x)g'(x)}dx = f(x)g(x) - \int{f'(x)g(x)}dx$$

which gave me the following: $$ 2x\sqrt{x+3} - \int{2\sqrt{x+3}} dx$$

There is no point continuing beyond this point in my calculation as Wolfram Alpha has told me that the result of the above computation is different from the initial integral.

I have starred at this for a while. I had a friend stare at it too and neither of us could see a mistake.

This is my first time using LaTeX so I may have done a typo somewhere. Sorry about that.

Here are the two outputs:

Me: $$ 2x\sqrt{x+3}-4/3(x+3)^{3/2} + C $$ Alpha: $$ 2/3(x-6)\sqrt{x+3} + C$$

  • $\begingroup$ Remember that these are indefinite integrals, and your answer may disagree by a constant from Alpha (and still be correct). $\endgroup$ – vadim123 Mar 20 '18 at 0:59
  • $\begingroup$ The answer I get from evaluating your last expression (after some algebraic manipulation) gives the same result that WolframAlpha spits out. $\endgroup$ – Mauve Mar 20 '18 at 0:59
  • $\begingroup$ Integration by parts should work here. What do you get as your solution? $\endgroup$ – BSplitter Mar 20 '18 at 1:01
  • $\begingroup$ If you are unsure if you solution is the same as the solution that wolfram alpha has, try plotting both functions in Desmos. (desmos.com. ) $\endgroup$ – BSplitter Mar 20 '18 at 1:03
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Will think of comparing them more next time before posting. Thanks everybody! $\endgroup$ – Slava Knyazev Mar 20 '18 at 1:06

WolframAlpha says the original integral comes to $\frac{2}{3}(x - 6)\sqrt{x + 3} + c$. It says the new integral (after integration by parts) is $2x\sqrt{x + 3} - \frac{4}{3}(x + 3)^{3/2} + c$.

If we factor $\sqrt{x + 3}$ out of the second one, we have $(2x - \frac{4}{3}(x + 3))\sqrt{x + 3} + c$. $2x - \frac{4}{3}(x + 3) = 2x - \frac{4}{3}x - 4 = \frac{2}{3}x - 4 = \frac{2}{3}(x - 6)$. So these two expressions are the same!

Here's a tip: If you find yourself in a situation where you think you have two different answers, try plugging in several values of $x$. There are three possibilities:

  • You get the same value for each no matter which $x$ you use (like this situation); that means they're secretly the same, and you should look for an algebraic way to simplify one into the other.
  • You get different values, but the two expressions always differ by the same amount; that means they're just getting different $+c$ values.
  • You get wildly different values; that means you did something wrong!
  • $\begingroup$ +1 for the great general tips next to answering the question! $\endgroup$ – Jan Mar 20 '18 at 13:19

You have $$2x\sqrt{x+3} - \int{2\sqrt{x+3}} dx $$

For the integral $$ \int{2\sqrt{x+3}} dx$$

Make the substitution $$x+3=u $$ and you have $$ \int{2\sqrt{x+3}} dx =2\int{\sqrt{u}} du$$

You know how to finish it.


Without any substitution and without any integration by parts:

$$\int \frac{x}{\sqrt{x+3}}\, dx= \int \frac{x+3-3}{\sqrt{x+3}}\, dx= \int \sqrt{x+3}\, dx - 3\int \frac{1}{\sqrt{x+3}}\, dx =$$ $$ = \frac{2}{3}(x+3)\sqrt{x+3}-6\sqrt{x+3} =\frac{2}{3}(x-6)\sqrt{x+3}$$


I believe you can go further in your computation by assuming $u = x + 3$ ; you'll eventually end up at the same result as provided by Wolfram Alpha. In my solution here, I would like to present another plausible solution for the given integral, which however does not use Integration by parts.

Let $u = x + 3 \implies x = u - 3$ and $du = dx$

Therefore the integral reduces to :- $$\int{\frac{u - 3}{\sqrt{u}}} du$$

$$ = \int{[\sqrt{u} - 3u^{\frac{-1}{2}}}] du$$ $$ = \frac 23 (x+3)^{\frac 32} - 6\sqrt{x+3} + C$$ $$ = \sqrt{x+3} * [\frac23 (x+3) - 6]$$ which on solving a little further (Solve it yourself to confirm) yields the following result -

$$ = \frac23 \sqrt{x+3} (x - 6) + C$$

as given by Wolfram Alpha as well.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.