Problem: Suppose $S$ is a subset of a manifold $M$, and for every point $p \in S$, there exists an open neighbourhood $U$ around $p$ such that $S \cap U$ is a submanifold of the neighbourhood $U$. Show that $S$ is in fact a submanifold of the manifold $M$. This problem is quite similar to Lemma 5.5 in Lee's smooth manifold book (which he did not prove).

Attempt: Pick $p \in S$ and find the corresponding neighbourhood $U$. We can easily extend the submanifold charts $\{U_{\alpha} \cap U,\phi_{\alpha}|_U \}$ for $U$ (looking at $U$ as a submanifold of $M$) to the whole manifold $M$, and if we are lucky enough to have the $U_{\alpha} \cap S \subset U \cap S$ then we are good for the point $p$. But if $U \cap S \subsetneq U_{\alpha} \cap S$, I cannot say that $\phi_{\alpha}(U_{\alpha} \cap S) = \phi_{\alpha}(U_{\alpha}) \cap \mathbb{R}^k \subset \mathbb{R}^n$, so I need to find some way to "glue" the remaining parts of $U_{\alpha} \cap S$ onto the set while proving that $\phi_{\alpha}(U_{\alpha} \cap S) = \mathbb{R}^k \cap \phi_{\alpha} (U_{\alpha})$. I am stuck at this step, because simply finding another neighbourhood that actually covers $(U_{\alpha} \cap S) - (U \cap S)$ and coming up with charts on it just give me diffeomorphisms by composing the charts, and I am not sure whether that could help me proving that $\phi_{\alpha}$ does "straighten out" the $(U_{\alpha} \cap S) - (U \cap S)$. Any help is appreciated!


You don't need to have $U_\alpha\cap S\subset U\cap S$, if $U_\alpha$ is a chart, every connected component of $U_\alpha\cap U$ is a chart. Take the connected component $V_\alpha$ which contains $p$ and restrict $\phi_\alpha$ to $V_\alpha$.

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you for the answer. I don't think we studied this in class... could you elaborate on it a bit more or point me to a source for this? Thanks again! $\endgroup$ – Longti Mar 11 '18 at 4:39
  • $\begingroup$ look the definition of an atlas $(U_\alpha,\phi_\alpha)$ you can add charts in the atlas like so, if $U$ is an open subset, define the new atlas whose charts are $(U_\alpha,\phi\alpha)$ and $(V_\alpha,{\phi_\alpha}_{\mid V_\alpha})$ where $V_\alpha$ is a connected component of $U\cap U_\alpha$. $\endgroup$ – Tsemo Aristide Mar 11 '18 at 4:48
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks a lot for your answer. $\endgroup$ – Longti Mar 11 '18 at 5:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.