4
$\begingroup$

Prove $$\Delta=\begin{vmatrix} (y+z)^2 & x^2 & x^2 \\ y^2 & (z+x)^2 & y^2 \\ z^2 & z^2 & (x+y)^2 \\ \end{vmatrix} = 2xyz(x+y+z)^3$$ using factor theorem.

This is solved in Demonstrate using determinant properties that the determinant of A is equal to $2abc(a+b+c)^3$ using factor theorem.

My Attempt:

$$ x=0\text{ or }y=0\text{ or }z=0\implies\Delta=0\text{ , So $x,y,z$ are factors of }\Delta.\\ (x+y+z)=0\implies \Delta=\begin{vmatrix}x^2&x^2&x^2\\y^2&y^2&y^2\\z^2&z^2&z^2\end{vmatrix}=0\text{ , So $(x+y+z)$ is a factor of $\Delta$.} $$ $\color{black}{\text{But how do i extract the remaining term $(x+y+z)^2$ to prove $\Delta=2xyz(x+y+z)^3$ }\color{red}{ ?}}$

Similar Example:

Please check answer of @user348749 in How to solve this determinant, $$ \Delta'=\begin{vmatrix} (b+c)^2&ab&ca\\ ab&(a+c)^2&bc\\ ac&bc&(a+b)^2 \end{vmatrix}=2abc(a+b+c)^3 $$ it is said that $$ (a+b+c)=0\implies\Delta'=\begin{align*} \begin{vmatrix} c^2 & ca & bc \\ ca & a^2 & ab \\ bc & ab & b^2 \\ \end{vmatrix} =abc\begin{vmatrix} c & a & b \\ c & a & b \\ c & a & b \\ \end{vmatrix} \end{align*}=0 $$ "Since all rows are identical, $(a+b+c)^2$ is a factor. The determinant is a polynomial of degree 6 and hence the remaining factor is linear and since it is symmetric, the factor must be $k(a+b+c)$."

$\color{black}{\text{How can we say this }\color{red}{ ?}}$

My Understanding:

If the problem was similar to this, answer of @Saibal in Factorise a matrix using the factor theorem, $$\Delta''= \begin{vmatrix} x&y&z\\ x^2&y^2&z^2\\ x^3&y^3&z^3\\ \end{vmatrix}$$ I could without doubt do as below: $$ x=0\text{ or }y=0\text{ or }z=0\implies\Delta''=0\\ x=y\text{ or }y=z\text{ or }z=x\implies\Delta''=0 $$ Thus, $x,y,z,(x-y),(y-z),(z-x)$ are factors of $\Delta''$. ie. $\Delta''=kxyz(x-y)(y-z)(z-x)$

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

Your attempt is fine. And all the further explanations you need are already given by user348749 in How to solve this determinant I could just rephrase this here: Since for $x+y+z=0$, all three columns are identical (same argument as all three rows), $(x+y+z)^2$ is a factor (see user348749's explanation). So the remaining factor is linear. Since $\Delta$ does not change under $x \leftrightarrow y$ or any other permutation, the remaining linear factor must be symmetric under these exchanges, and only $C \cdot (x+y+z)$ is such a factor. Again, not my arguments so far, but user348749's.

The thing that remains to be done is to calculate the constant. Choose e.g. $x=y=z=1$ and you get $$ \Delta=\begin{vmatrix} 4 & 1 & 1 \\ 1 & 4 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 & 4 \\ \end{vmatrix} = 4\cdot 15 - 2\cdot 3 =54 = C \cdot 3^3 = C \cdot 27 $$ which clearly gives $C =2$.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ thnx. So is it like, whn i put $x=-y-z$ and taken out $x,y,z$ from $R_2,R_3,R_1$ respectively, then $R_1=R_2=R_3$. ie. When we take $x,y,z$ from $R_2,R_3,R_1$ respectively, and apply $R_1\to R_1-R_2$ and $R_3\to R_3-R_2$ and set $x=-y-z$ then $R_1=0$ and $R_3=0$, that means $(x+y+z)$ can be taken out from both $R_1-R_2$ and $R_3-R_2$ along with $xyz$, Hence $(x+y+z)^2$ can be taken out as a factor. right ? $\endgroup$ – ss1729 Feb 22 '18 at 5:45
  • $\begingroup$ I think for people who are unfamiliar of symmetric polynomials its is kinda confusing to just mention symmetry in such problems. I had to do a lot of reading myself to even get a hint into understanding the solutions. $\endgroup$ – ss1729 Feb 23 '18 at 19:57
  • $\begingroup$ "the determinant is invariant under $S_3$. That means that all its factors are also symmetric polynomials". I do not think that this argument is correct broadly, as "Not all symmetric polynomials factor into symmetric factors", Ex:$(x+y)(y+z)(z+x)$. $\endgroup$ – ss1729 Feb 23 '18 at 20:25
  • $\begingroup$ So far we have obtained $xyz(x+y+z)^2$. Thus the remaining factor must be none other than $(x+y+z)$ else it'd never be symmetric. Ex: If it was $x$ or $y$ or $z$ then $x.xyz(x+y+z)^2$ is not symmetric. Two factors alone cannot sustain a permutation of the variables, as $(x+y)xyz(x+y+z)^2$ not symmetric. Thus the only possible factor which preserve the polynomial to be symmetric is $(x+y+z)$. $\endgroup$ – ss1729 Feb 23 '18 at 20:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.