$\displaystyle{\lim_{ x \rightarrow a}}\;\frac{a^x-x^a}{x-a}\;\;$

I don't know what i've been doing wrong. I've triying to solve it, using this remarkable limit:

$\displaystyle{\lim_{ x \rightarrow 0}}\; \frac{a^{kx}-1}{x}=k\;ln(a)\;\;$ ln is the natural log

Since the limit has to approach 0, to use the remarkable, i did a variable change.

Let $u=x-a$, if $x\rightarrow a$ then $u \rightarrow 0$, this means that $x=u+a$


$\displaystyle{\lim_{ u \rightarrow 0}}\; \dfrac{a^{u+a}-(u+a)^{a}}{u}$

$=\displaystyle{\lim_{ u \rightarrow 0}}\; \dfrac{a^{u+a}-(u+a)^{a}-1+1}{u}\;\;$ (Substrac and add 1 to numerator)

$=\displaystyle{\lim_{ u \rightarrow 0}}\; \dfrac{(a^{u+a}-1)-((u+a)^{a}-1)}{u}\;\;$ (Common factor (-1))

$=\displaystyle{\lim_{ u \rightarrow 0}}\; \dfrac{a^{u+a}-1}{u}-\dfrac{(u+a)^{a}-1}{u}$

$=\displaystyle{\lim_{ u \rightarrow 0}}\; \dfrac{\dfrac{(u+a)[a^{u+a}-1]}{u+a}}{u}-\dfrac{\dfrac{a[(u+a)^{a}-1]}{a}}{u}\;\; $ (common factor (u+a) and (a))

I don't know if the steps that come next are right

$=\displaystyle{\lim_{ u \rightarrow 0}}\; \dfrac{(u+a)ln(a)}{u}-\dfrac{(a)ln(u+a)}{u}\;\;$ (Apply remarkable limit)

$=\displaystyle{\lim_{ u \rightarrow 0}}\; \dfrac{ln(a^{u+a})}{u}-\dfrac{ln(u+a^{a})}{u}$

And here is where I'm lost, i don't know what to do next. Wolfram alpha says that:

$\displaystyle{\lim_{ x \rightarrow a}}\;\frac{a^x-x^a}{x-a}= a^aln(a)-a^a\;\;$

I can't use l'Hôpital rule

  • $\begingroup$ You started off correctly, but made the wrong split. You have to add and subtract $a^a$ and not $1$. $\endgroup$ – Paramanand Singh Feb 13 '18 at 3:04

You can proceed as $$\frac{a^{u+a} - (u+a) ^{a} - a^a+a^a} {u} =\frac{a^{u+a} - a^a} {u} - \frac{(u+a) ^{a} - a^a} {u} $$ The first term can be written as $$a^a\cdot\frac{a^u-1}{u}$$ which tends to $a^a\log a$ via the remarkable limit. The second term needs to be put back in the form of $x$ to get $$\frac{x^a-a^a} {x-a} $$ and this tends to $aa^{a-1}=a^a$ via another remarkable limit $$\lim_{x\to a} \frac{x^n-a^n} {x-a} =na^{n-1}$$ Combining the above we get final limit as $a^a\log a-a^a$.

Apart from making the wrong split using $-1+1$ (this is correct mathematically but does not help to reach the goal) your approach has some mistakes which are mathematically incorrect. Thus you multiply / divide by $(u+a) $ and then incorrectly apply the remarkable limit. The limit applies only when denominator tends to $0$ but here denominator $u+a\to a$. Moreover in this process you are not taking full limit, rather the limit of part of an expression. This is another thing which is forbidden.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for your answer sir, you are very kind. $\endgroup$ – Diego Sánchez Feb 13 '18 at 12:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.