I wish to show $\mathbb{R}[X,Y]/(X^2 + Y^2 -1)$ is not isomorphic to $\mathbb{R}[T,T^{-1}]$ (where $X,Y,T$ are formal variables in the bigger polynomial rings$.

I have tried to compare the basic properties, e.g. they are both integral domains but they seem to agree. Can I exploit the way $\mathbb{R}$ is not algebraically closed somehow? Since I have shown the result is true for $\mathbb{C}$ in place of $\mathbb{R}$.


2 Answers 2


$\mathbb{R}[T, T^{-1}]$ is the localization of a UFD (a PID, even), hence is a UFD. However, $\mathbb{R}[X,Y]/(X^2 + Y^2 - 1)$ is not a UFD: the idea is that $X^2 = (1-Y)(1+Y)$ gives two different factorizations. For details, see this answer.

The interesting part is that if we work over $\mathbb{C}$, the two corresponding rings $\mathbb{C}[X,Y]/(X^2 + Y^2 - 1)$ and $\mathbb{C}[T,T^{-1}]$ are isomorphic: $$ \mathbb{C}[T,T^{-1}] \cong \mathbb{C}[T,U]/(TU - 1) \cong \mathbb{C}[X,Y]/(X^2 + Y^2 - 1) $$ where the last isomorphism sends $T \mapsto X + iY$ and $U \mapsto X - iY$.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Very nice idea. $\endgroup$
    – egreg
    Feb 11, 2018 at 19:58

If $\xi$ and $\eta$ are the images of $X$ and $Y$ in the quotient ring, then $\xi^2+\eta^2=1$, so you should find two such elements in $\mathbb{R}[T,T^{-1}]$.

An nonzero element in $\mathbb{R}[T,T^{-1}]$ can be uniquely written as $T^mf(T)$, where $m$ is an integer and $f(T)\in\mathbb{R}[T]$ with $f(0)\ne0$. So suppose $$ (T^mf(T))^2+(T^ng(T))^2=1 $$ Suppose $m\ge0$ and $n\ge0$. Then the leading coefficient of the left-hand side is positive, so the degree has to be zero, which implies $m=n=0$ and $f$ and $g$ constant.

However, the images of $\xi$ and $\eta$ should generate $\mathbb{R}[T,T^{-1}]$: contradiction.

Suppose $m<0$ and, without loss of generality, $m\le n$. Then we get $$ f(T)^2+T^{2n-2m}g(T)^2=T^{-2m} $$ Evaluating at $0$, we obtain $f(0)^2=0$ or $f(0)^2+g(0)^2=0$ (according to $n\ne m$ or $n=m$): in both cases it is a contradiction.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.