$a_2 = 2$

$a_2^{a_3 } = 3$

So $a_3= \ln(3)/\ln(2)$.

I wonder about all solutions $a_n$ such that

$a_2^{a_3^{\dots^{a_n}}} = n$

For all $n$.

How does $a_n$ behave? What are the best asymptotics?

Of course $a_n$ goes quickly towards values between $\exp(1/e)$ and $1$ that is trivial.

But I am not even sure If $a_n$ is strictly decreasing or if its limit exists.

Also If it is strictly decreasing with limit $A$ , I do not know the value of $A$.

I assume $A=1$.

I assume $A=1$ Because $a_2 = 2$. We could consider other starting values and define ( assuming a limit ) $A(a_2)$ as a function. If that function is even continuous or $C^1$ is another matter.


We can't have $a_n\to a<\exp(1/e)$. If we did, then there must exist some $N$ such that $a_n<\exp(1/e)$ for all $n>N$, and then we'd have


which is bounded, while $n$ is unbounded.

We also can't have $a_n\to a>\exp(1/e)$, since then the power tower would have a lower bound that grows asymptotically faster than $n$ ($x^{x^{\dots}}$ diverges for $x>\exp(1/e)$).

Hence, we conclude that we must have $a_n\to\exp(1/e)$, if it approaches any limit at all. We also deduce that we must have $a_n\ge\exp(1/e)$ for infinitely many $n$, since $x^{x^{\dots}}$ converges for $x=\exp(1/e)$. So if the sequence is monotone, it must be decreasing.

  • $\begingroup$ Ah Yes Thank you. +1. The question reduced to “ monotone “ and If So to asymptotics of 1/(a_n - exp(1/e)) I would say. $\endgroup$ – mick Aug 22 '18 at 23:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.