The book Understanding Analysis by Stephen Abbott asserts that

$$ g(x)=\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{1}{2^n}h(2^nx), $$

where $h(x)=\left|x\right|$, $h:\left[-1,1\right]\to\mathbb{R}$, and $h(x+2)=h(x)$, is continuous on all of $\mathbb{R}$ but fails to be differentiable at any point.

However, if I am not mistaken, can the $2^n$'s be cancelled out in $g$? I tried plotting this and could not obtain a nowhere-differentiable function.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ This function is called a Blancmange function, and you can easily google its nowhere differentiability. Anyway, your primary mistake is that $h(ax) = ah(x)$ does not hold even for $a > 0$. Note that $h(x)$ differs from $|x|$. $\endgroup$ – Sangchul Lee Dec 14 '12 at 4:27

The plot looks like this. It's hard to tell by a casual look that this is nowhere differentiable.

enter image description here

For a better view of what's going on, here's an animation that zooms into the graph. You can see that the picture looks similar at different length scales. A differentiable curve, on the other hand, would look more and more like a straight line as you zoomed in. enter image description here

EDIT: I plotted this in Maple. I don't have the code any more, but it might have been something like this.

h:= x -> abs(x - 2*round(x/2)):
g:= unapply(add(1/2^n*h(2^n*x), n=0..1000),x):
x0:= 0.23456: y0:= evalf(g(x0)): r:= 1.13:
for i from 0 to 99 do
  frame[i]:= plot(r^i*(g(x/r^i + x0) - y0), x=-1..1, axes=none, 
      title = sprintf("Zoom factor %7.1f",r^i))
  • $\begingroup$ Oops, factor of $\pi$ left out (I was using $\arccos(\cos(\pi x))/\pi$ for $h$): I'll fix it. $\endgroup$ – Robert Israel Dec 14 '12 at 6:55
  • $\begingroup$ How are you getting this plot $ i.e. $ in which software are you piloting this ? Cold you please give the code? $\endgroup$ – Sachchidanand Prasad Sep 4 '15 at 16:13

No, the $2^n$s cannot be cancelled out, as William Macrae and sos440 have pointed out.

$h$ is a zig zag function. $h(2^nx)$ is like $h$ but with the zig zags squished in toward the $y$-axis, making it go up and down more rapidly, but at the same height. Then $\dfrac1{2^n} h(2^nx)$ is like $h(2^nx)$ but with the zig zags squished down toward the $x$-axis, making them a lot shorter.

The $1/2^n$ out front ensures that the series converges uniformly (and hence that the resulting function is continuous), because $h$ is bounded. The combination of $2^n$s ensures that each term has zig zags of slope $\pm1$, while the number of zig zags per unit interval doubles from one term to the next.


The $2^n$s cannot be cancelled because one is inside of the function $h$ (which is not affine). This is the same reason that $2 \sin(\frac12 x) \neq \sin(x)$ (for arbitrary $x$). The function that is being described is qualitatively the sum of more-and-more fine-grained 'zig-zag' functions; it's likely you are not plotting it quite right, so try plotting just one term first.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.