Let $$f_1:U_1 \to \mathbb{R}^2 \quad f_1(t)=(\cos t, \sin t)\quad U_1=(-\pi, \pi)$$ $$f_2:U_2 \to \mathbb{R}^2 \quad f_2(t)=(\cos t, \sin t)\quad U_2=(\pi/2, 3\pi/2)$$

Show that $f_1^{-1}\bigg(f_1(U_1) \cap f_2(U_2)\bigg) $ is open.

I tried various methods but I keep running into problems.

For example the intersection is an arc, which is not open in $\mathbb{R}^2$, so I cannot just claim the statement is true due to continuity of $f$.

So I tried in the most basic way:

$p\in f_1^{-1}\bigg(f_1(U_1) \cap f_2(U_2)\bigg)\subset f^{-1}(f(U_1)) \implies \exists r\in U_1$ such that $f_1(r)=f_1(p)$

Because $U_1$ is open, $r+\epsilon\in U_1$, but $f(r+\epsilon)$ is not necessarily in the intersection.

Not sure what else to do.

Using DeMorgans

$f_1^{-1}\bigg(f_1(U_1) \cap f_2(U_2)\bigg) = f_1^{-1}(f_1(U_1)) \cap f_1^{-1}(f_2(U_2)) \supset U_1 \cap U_2$

  • $\begingroup$ Inverse images commute with intersections. $\endgroup$ – Randall Dec 14 '17 at 22:07
  • $\begingroup$ @Randall, Cannot belief I forgot about DeMorgan's I'll give it a shot $\endgroup$ – PMM Dec 14 '17 at 22:11
  • $\begingroup$ @Randall Actually I had already tried that approach. I don't see what to do with it because you have that the preimage of the image of a set is a supset of that set. $\endgroup$ – PMM Dec 14 '17 at 22:17

A useful lemma:

Let $g : X \to Y$ be an injection and $A \subseteq X$. Then $g^{-1}(g(A)) = A$.

Taking the preimage commutes with $\cap$ so we have:

$$f_1^{-1}(f_1(U_1) \cap f_2(U_2)) = f_1^{-1}(f_1(U_1)) \cap f_1^{-1}(f_2(U_2))$$

$f_1$ is injective so $f_1^{-1}(f_1(U_1)) = U_1$.

On the other hand, $$f_2(U_2) = f_1\left(\left\langle -\pi, -\frac{3\pi}2\right\rangle \cup \left\langle \frac\pi2, \pi\right\rangle\right) \cup \{(-1,0)\}$$

but $(-1, 0) \notin \operatorname{Im} f_1$ so

$$f_1^{-1}(f_2(U_2)) = f_1^{-1}\left(f_1\left(\left\langle -\pi, -\frac{3\pi}2\right\rangle \cup \left\langle \frac\pi2, \pi\right\rangle\right)\right) = \left\langle -\pi, -\frac{3\pi}2\right\rangle \cup \left\langle \frac\pi2, \pi\right\rangle$$

again because $f_1$ is injective.


$$f_1^{-1}(f_1(U_1) \cap f_2(U_2)) = U_1 \cap \underbrace{\left(\left\langle -\pi, -\frac{3\pi}2\right\rangle \cup \left\langle \frac\pi2, \pi\right\rangle\right)}_{\subseteq U_1} = \left\langle -\pi, -\frac{3\pi}2\right\rangle \cup \left\langle \frac\pi2, \pi\right\rangle$$

which is certainly an open set in $U_1$.

  • $\begingroup$ The lemma is what I was missing mostly. Regarding notation, are the angle brackets open or closed sets? $\endgroup$ – PMM Dec 14 '17 at 22:31
  • $\begingroup$ @PMM The angle brackets are open intervals: $$(x,y) = \langle x, y \rangle$$ Of course, you can calculate $f_1(U_1)$ and $f_2(U_2)$ explicitly as they are simply arcs on the unit circle. Then intersect them, and notice that the intersection is open and $f_1$ is continuous. $\endgroup$ – mechanodroid Dec 14 '17 at 22:39

Best if you draw it in a picture.

The point $(\cos t,\,\sin t)$ is just the point on the unit circle the radius of which encloses angle $t$ with the positive ray of $x$ axis. This angle $t$ is measured in radian, i.e. $\pi$ means $180^\circ$.

So, $f_1$ goes a full circle, not containing the starting = endpoint = $(-1,0)$ where $t=\pm\pi$. In other words, $f_1(U_1)$ is the circle minus this point $(-1,0)$.

And $f_2$ goes the left half circle from $\pi/2$ i.e. $90^\circ$ to $3\pi/2$ i.e. $270^\circ$, again not containing the endpoints.

Looking at the picture, clearly $f_1(U_1)\cap f_2(U_2)$ is $f_2(U_2)\setminus\{(-1,0)\}$.
Writing back the points of this to angles, using the range $U_1=(-\pi,\pi)$ we get exactly its preimage along $f_1$, which will be a union of two open intervals.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.