I have two variables x and y. They are governed by the two equations -

$$x+y = 1$$ and

$$2x + 3y = 5$$

Upon solving the two equations, I get $x = -2$ and $y = 3$.

Then, the value of $5x + 4y$ would be $2$. Another way to get this value would be to use the equation

$$k(x+y) + j(2x + 3y) = x + y$$

Solving for k and j, I get $k = 7$ and $j = -1$ and thus, the value of $5x + 4y$ would be $7(1) - 5(-1)$ which is again equal to 2. While this is simple enough, I found a problem with three variables - x, y and z. The two equations governing these variables are

$$3x + 4y + 10 z = 252$$ and

$$x - 2y +z = 0$$

and I ned to find the value of $x + y +z$.

Using the method illustrated above, that is,

$$k(3x + 4y + 10z) + j (x - 2y + z) = x + y +z$$

and I get three equations in $k$ and $j$ which are

$$3k + j = 1$$ $$4k - 2j = 1$$ $$10k + j = 1$$

Solving the first two equations, I get $k = \frac{3}{10}$ and $j = \frac{1}{10}$.

Solving the second and third equations, I get $k = \frac{1}{8}$ and $j = \frac{-1}{4}$.

Solving the first and third equations, I get $k = 0$ and $j = 1$.

The values of $x + y + z$ in each of the above solutions would be $75.6$, $31.5$ and $0$, none of which is the right answer.

Obviously, the method from the previous illustration fails here as I get three distinct values of k & j, none of which is correct. Is it because I have made a silly arithmetic error here that I am not able to detect, or is it that I have 3 equations in 2 variables, leading to multiple solutions?

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ When you chose to solve a subset of two equations : the first two, the first and third, and the last and third, then you get values of $k,j$ accordingly. However, none of them are correct, since they don't satisfy all three solutions. What this means, of course, is that $x+y+z$ cannot be written linearly as a combination of $x-2y+z$ and $3x+4y+10z$. Then $x+y+z$ can take any value as desired. $\endgroup$ Dec 5 '17 at 4:07
  • $\begingroup$ does this mean that I cannot uniquely solve for x, y and z from the above two equations? $\endgroup$ Dec 5 '17 at 4:12
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ No, I've solved it and got $y = \frac 7{24}(x+36), z = -5x\frac{5x}{12}$. Thus, $x+y+z$ is some function of $x$, so varying $x$ will allow us to vary $x+y+z$ freely. $\endgroup$ Dec 5 '17 at 4:15

Notice that

$$\begin{bmatrix} 3 & 4 & 10 \\1 & -2 & 1 \\1 & 1 & 1\end{bmatrix}$$ is non-singular.

Hence we can set $x+y+z$ to be anything and we can recover a unique solution of $x,y,z$.

The first two equations doesn't uniquely determined the value of $x+y+z$. It can be set to any value.

Your trick works if the third row lies in the span of the first two rows which is not the case here.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.