6
$\begingroup$

Consider the integral $$I_n \equiv \int_{t_1=0}^T dt_1 \int_{t_2 = t_1}^T dt_2 \cdots \int_{t_n = t_{n-1}}^T dt_n \, .$$ I suspect the result should be $I_n = T^n/n!$ but would like to prove it. Doing the $n^\text{th}$ integral gives \begin{align} I_n &= \int_{t_1=0}^T dt_1 \cdots \int_{t_{n-1}=t_{n-2}}^T dt_{n-1} \, (T-t_{n-1}) \\ &= T I_{n-1} - \int_{t_1=0}^T dt_1 \dots \int_{t_{n-1}=t_{n-2}}^T dt_{n-1} \, t_{n-1} \, . \end{align} Is there some way to evaluate the second term or to come up with a useful recurrence relation or induction step?

$\endgroup$
0
5
$\begingroup$

I think induction is your best bet here, and it doesn't even really require any $I_n$ notation. We can simply evaluate the integral on it's own. Starting with your first step, which you did correctly, we begin to integrate. $$\int_{t_1=0}^T dt_1 \int_{t_2 = t_1}^T dt_2 \cdots \int_{t_n = t_{n-1}}^T dt_n = \int_{t_1=0}^T dt_1 \int_{t_2 = t_1}^T dt_2 \cdots\int_{t_{n-1}=t_{n-2}}^T (T-t_{n-1})dt_{n-1}$$ Integrating by power rule (and chain rule for the negative), we get $$\int_{t_1=0}^T dt_1 \int_{t_2 = t_1}^T dt_2 \cdots\int_{t_{n-2}=t_{n-3}}^T -\frac{(T-t_{n-1})^{2}}{2!} \Bigg|_{t_{n-2}}^{T} dt_{n-2} \\ =\cdots\int_{t_{n-2}=t_{n-3}}^T -\frac{\left(T-T\right)^2}{2!} -\left(-\frac{\left(T-t_{n-2}\right)^2}{2!}\right) dt_{n-2} \\ = \cdots\int_{t_{n-2}=t_{n-3}}^T \frac{\left(T-t_{n-2}\right)^2}{2!}dt_{n-2}$$ And finally, we see a pattern, so let us prove the induction step $$\int_{t_{k}=t_{k-1}}^T\frac{(T-t_k)^a}{a!} dt_k = -\frac{(T-t_k)^{a+1}}{(a+1)!}\Bigg|_{t_{k-1}}^T = \frac{(T-t_{k-1})^{a+1}}{(a+1)!}$$ Now that we have that, we integrate along until we get to the final integral with $t_1$ $$\int_{t_1=0}^T \frac{(T-t_1)^{n-1}}{(n-1)!}dt_1 = -\frac{(T-t_1)^n}{n!} \Bigg|_0^T = \frac{T^n}{n!}$$ And there we have the answer: the volume of a regular right simplex!

$\endgroup$
3
  • $\begingroup$ I don't understand where $-(T-T)^2/2!$ comes from. I submitted an edit to remove it, but apparently it was rejected. $\endgroup$ – DanielSank Dec 6 '17 at 19:18
  • $\begingroup$ It comes from the fact that we are evaluating a definite integral. I will add a line above to show this. $\endgroup$ – Isaac Browne Dec 6 '17 at 19:52
  • $\begingroup$ Oh I see. I would have integrated the $T$ and $-t_{n-1}$ separately, but your way is better. $\endgroup$ – DanielSank Dec 6 '17 at 20:02
2
$\begingroup$

Here's an alternative, albeit perhaps a less inspiring approach. The way to read off that the integral $$I_n = \int_0^T dt_1 \int_{t_1}^T dt_2 \cdots \int_{t_{n-1}}^T dt_n$$ is measuring volume of the regular right $n$-simplex of height $T$ is to see that the domain of the integral is $V = \{(t_1, t_2, \cdots, t_n) \in \Bbb R^{n+1} : t_{k-1} \leq t_k \leq T; t_0 = 0 \}$. This is the convex subset of $\Bbb R^{n+1}$ defined by the set of linear inequalities $0 \leq t_1 \leq \cdots \leq t_n \leq T$; one can easily see that this is nothing other than a simplex (inductive argument: fix a $t_1 = t_{01}$ and observe that at that slice it's just the same convex subset in one dimension lower. It's clearly a simplex for $n = 1$.)

Here's a picture for $n = 2$ (stolen from Shifrin's "Multivariable Mathematics"):enter image description here

where $t_1 = x$ and $t_2 = y$ are the variables in the convention of the image. Here we have changed the slices of the volume from $(t_1 = c)$'s for various $c \in [0, T]$ to $(t_2 = c)$'s for various $c \in [0, T]$. What this accomplishes is the following; we change the limits of our integral to $0 \leq t_2 \leq T$ and $0 \leq t_2 \leq t_1$, and accordingly switches the order of the integrals:

$$I_2 = \int_0^T dt_1 \int_{t_1}^T dt_2 = \int_0^T dt_2 \int_0^{t_2} dt_1$$

We can similarly generalize. Change the limits (and order) of the integral $I_n$ from the inequalities $0 \leq t_1 \leq T, t_1 \leq t_2 \leq T, \cdots, t_{n-1} \leq t_n \leq T$ to $0 \leq t_n \leq T, 0 \leq t_{n-1} \leq t_n, \cdots, 0 \leq t_1 \leq t_2$. Hence, we obtain the equality $$I_n = \int_0^T dt_n \int_0^{t_n} dt_{n-1} \cdots \int_0^{t_2} dt_1$$

Notice that this is secretly nothing but Fubini; we have changed the order of integrals. Now, why is this useful? Just notice that we can start evaluating the integral from the innermost iterated integral

$$\begin{align} I_n = \int_0^T dt_n \int_0^{t_n} dt_{n-1} \cdots \int_0^{t_3} dt_2 \int_0^{t_2} dt_1 & = \int_0^T dt_n \int_0^{t_n} dt_{n-1} \cdots \int_0^{t_{k+1}} dt_k \; t_k^{k-1}/(k-1)! \\ &= \int_0^T dt_n \; t_n^{n-1}/(n-1)! \\ &= T^n/n!\end{align}$$

So your integral is indeed the volume of the regular right-angled $n$-simplex of height $T$ which is indeed equal to $T^n/n!$.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.