0
$\begingroup$

In Halmos's book under section 5, one of the definitions call for the proof of:

$$A \cap (B-C) = (A \cap B) - (A \cap C) = (A \cap B) \cap (A \cap C)^c $$

So I figured, ok, under the distributive property, one would obtain the following. Exploring the LHS I realize that I don't exactly get the equality, for example doing the approach through associativity:

$$ A \cap (B \cap C^c) = (A \cap B) \cap C^c = (A \cap B) - C $$

that doesn't seem right, or following through the distributive property + De Morgans law:

$$ A \cap (B \cap C^c) = (A \cap B) \cap (A \cap C^c) $$ $$ (A \cap B) \cap (A \cap C^c) = (A \cap B)\cap (A^c \cup C)^c $$ $$ (A \cap B)\cap (A^c \cup C)^c = (A \cap B)-(A^c \cup C) $$

Unless I'm missing some fact that involves $ A \cap C \subset C $, or details regarding $ x \in (A \cap C^c) $, I don't get this particular portion:

$$ (A \cap B) - (A \cap C) \neq (A \cap B)-(A^c \cup C) \neq (A \cap B) - C $$

I do hope you can enlighten me, and confirm that I am indeed a damned fool (im pretty sure I missed something). Thanks.

P.S I also apologize in advance if there are similar questions.

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

For the left part, we have to use the definition of (relative) complement to get:

$A \cap (B \setminus C)=A \cap (B \cap C^c)$

and

$(A \cap B) \setminus (A \cap C)= (A \cap B) \cap (A \cap C)^c=(A \cap B) \cap (A^c \cup C^c)=[(A \cap B) \cap A^c] \cup [(A \cap B) \cap C^c]$.

But: $(A \cap B) \cap A^c = (A \cap A^c) \cap B = \emptyset \cap B = \emptyset$, and thus from the above we get:

$(A \cap B) \setminus (A \cap C)= \emptyset \cup [(A \cap B) \cap C^c] = (A \cap B) \cap C^c.$



It seems to me that your mistake is assuming $\ne$ in the last "equation":

$x \in (A \cap B) \setminus (A \cap C) \text { iff } (x \in (A \cap B) \text { and } x \notin (A \cap C)).$

Thus:

$\text { iff } (x \in A \text { and } x \in B) \text { and } ( \text { either } x \notin A \text { or } x \notin C).$

But the first alternative is ruled out, because we have already $x \in A$, and thus we have:

$\text {iff } (x \in A \text { and } x \in B) \text { and } x \notin C \text { i.e. } x \in (A \cap B) \setminus C$.


In the same vain:

$x \in (A \cap B) \setminus (A^c \cup C) \text { iff } ((x \in A \text { and } x \in B) \text { and } x \notin (A^c \cup C)) \text { iff } ((x \in A \text { and } x \in B) \text { and } (x \notin A^c \text{ and } x \notin C)).$

But clearly, if $x \in A$ then $x \notin A^c$, and thus we simplify to:

$\text { iff } (x \in A \text { and } x \in B) \text { and } x \notin C.$

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ AH, right, so its the interpretation of my results at the end. Thank you very much. +1 $\endgroup$ – Cyrus Nov 22 '17 at 10:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.