I am trying to solve a problem that involves complex number. The original expression is extremely long but after debugging for several hours, I have identified the source of my error. When I do an arc tangent of the expression, with different values for the variable which are extremely close, the value jumps by order of magnitude.

The expression is: atan(var_z* (0.058659782 - 0.35747651i))*(161669.61 - 26529.028i)

When I use var_z = -20+3.282i, the value I get is 257585.794 - 19514.30i . When I use the value of var_z = -20+3.281i , the value I get is -250313.14 + 63829.09i .

What could be causing this? The expression is not supposed to have any step function. This is causing a big jump/discontinuity in my answer.

I feel like matlab is somehow messing up the atan function. Any help would be very much appreciated.


The real parts of the $\arctan$ function values without the factor jump by $\pi$ from $\approx -\tfrac{\pi}{2}$ to $\approx \tfrac{\pi}{2}:$

$$\arctan(( -20+3.281\cdot i)w) = -1.57079037+0.137054543\cdot i$$ $$\arctan(( -20+3.282\cdot i)w) = +1.57079553+.0137053434\cdot i$$

with $w=0.058659782 - 0.35747651\cdot i$.

Edit: For the arguments values you have

$$( -20+3.281\cdot i)w = -0.00031521069+7.34199294\cdot i$$ $$( -20+3.282\cdot i)w = +0.00004226582+7.34205160\cdot i$$ which are near the branch cut $\{ti: t\in\mathbb{R}, |t|\ge 1\}$ (see http://dlmf.nist.gov/4.23.ii), but at opposite sides. Your huge difference is the result of multiplying $\pi$ with $161669.61 - 26529.028\cdot i$.

The jump is normal, because you use the principal branch of $\arctan$.

  • $\begingroup$ Why is the real part switching signs when the input was reduced by just 0.001i? $\endgroup$ – John Joe Nov 14 '17 at 21:38
  • $\begingroup$ See the edit. $ $ $\endgroup$ – gammatester Nov 14 '17 at 22:26
  • $\begingroup$ Thank you! That explains the math. I think I am making some other mistakes in my code. $\endgroup$ – John Joe Nov 15 '17 at 4:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.