Let $N$ be a positive integer, $p$ be a prime not dividing $N$. It is a theorem of Igusa that the modular curve $X_1(N)$ has good reduction at $p$, call the reduction $\tilde{X_1}(N)$. If I'm understanding things correctly, this reduction should itself be representing some moduli problem (I'm already a little confused about how this works, but I don't think it matters so much for my main question). So points of $X_1(N)$ should correspond to elliptic curves $E$ with level structure, and the reduction map should send such a point to its reduction, again with some level structure.

My question then is, what happens to a point corresponding to an elliptic curve with bad reduction? It should be mapped to some point of $\tilde{X_1}(N)$, so it should correspond to some elliptic curve in characteristic $p$, but the reduction isn't an elliptic curve, so something must have gone wrong.


The closed curve $X_1(N)$ parameterizes not just elliptic curves with level structure (which correspond to the non-cuspidal points, the open subset of which is usually denoted $Y_1(N)$), but also degenerate elliptic curves (roughly speaking, nodal curves) with level structure (these are classified by the cusps).

The points on $Y_1(N)$ with bad reduction reduce to cusps on $\widetilde{X}_1(N)$.

A simple model to think about is $\mathbb A^1$ inside $\mathbb P^1$. A point in $\mathbb A^1$ over $\mathbb Q_p$ will have reduction lying in $\widetilde{\mathbb A}^1$ (here I'm using your notation; in this case I just mean the affine line over $\mathbb F_p$) if and only if it lies in $\mathbb Z_p$; elements of $\mathbb Q_p$ with non-trivial denominators have reduction equal to the point at infinity in $\widetilde{\mathbb P^1}$.

Another way to think about this is that $0$ is not the only element of $\mathbb Q_p$ whose reduction is zero mod $p$; any element of $\mathbb Q_p$ of positive valuation has reduction equal to zero mod $p$. Similarly, $\infty$ is not the only point of $\mathbb P^1(\mathbb Q_p)$ whose reduction is the point $\infty$ in $\mathbb P^1(\mathbb F_p)$; any element of $\mathbb Q_p$ with negative valuation has reduction equal to $\infty$.

  • $\begingroup$ Do we replace $[E,C]$ an elliptic curve with a subgroup by a cubic curve $E$ with $C$ defined by some rational maps $E \to E$ ? How to make sense to the isomorphism classes for them ? $\endgroup$ – reuns Oct 26 '17 at 1:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.