Let $K$ be the rational function field $k(x)$ over a perfect field $k$ of characteristic $p > 0$. Let $F = k(u)$ for some $u\in K$, and write $u = f(x)/g(x)$ with $f$ and $g$ relatively prime. Show that $K/F$ is a separable extension if and only if $u\notin K^p$.

There is already a post on this but it has not yet been answered : Patrick Morandi- Field and Galois Theory- Section 4- Exercise 11

The truth is that I am very confused with this problem, I would like someone please help me to understand what happens with this exercise and explain to me how it could be done by giving me a help or something. I already have an approach for the left-to-right implication, but I do not know very well how good it is. Could someone help me with the other implication please? Thank you very much.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ If $u = v^p$ with $v \in k(x) \setminus k$ then you have the tower $k(x)/k(v)/k(v^p)$. Possibly $k(x)/k(v)$ is separable. What about $k(v)/k(v^p)$ ? $\endgroup$ – reuns Oct 18 '17 at 22:20

Try this approach:

Consider the minimal $F$-polynomial for $x$, call it $H(T)$. It’s $F$-irreducible, and so of form $h(T^q)$ with $q=p^s$ for an $s\ge0$ and $h(T)$ an $F$-irreducible polynomial that’s separable.

If $s>0$, then $x$ is not separable over $F$ (and so $K$ is not separable over $F$), but $x^q$ is separable over $F$, as a root of the separable polynomial $h(T)$. We have $F\subset F(x^q)=K^q\subset F(x^p)=K^p\subset F(x)=K$. The last (rightmost) inclusion is strict, since $s>0$, and so $u\in K^p$.

On the other hand, if $s=0$, then $x$ is separable over $F$, the extension $K\supset F$ is separable, and $F\not\subset K^p=k(x^p)$: if we had had $F\subset k(x^p)$, then the minimal $F$-polynomial for $x$ as above would have $s>0$. Since $F\not\subset K^p$, it follows that $u\notin K^p$, since $u\in K^p\Rightarrow k(u)=F\subset K^p$.

So there are two mutually exclusive cases: $s>0$ with $K$ not separable over $F$ and $u\in K^p$; and $s=0$ with $K$ separable over $F$ and $u\notin K^p$.

This argument is not as neat and clear as I’d have liked. Maybe someone can do better.

  • $\begingroup$ I want to ask where do we need k is a perfect field? $\endgroup$ – Peter Liu Dec 23 '17 at 0:38
  • $\begingroup$ (at least) one place where perfectness is used is in the fourth paragraph (the one starting “On the other hand”) where I say that $K^p=k(x^p)$. Uses the fact that $k^p=k$. $\endgroup$ – Lubin Dec 23 '17 at 6:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.