I'm working my way through this paper (https://www.math.ubc.ca/~gerg/teaching/613-Winter2011/LargeSieveBombieriVinogradov.pdf) and am not quite seeing how one goes from (Lemma 3 page 3):

Note: $\lambda_{r}$'s are positive distinct real numbers and the z denote complex numbers.

$\sum_{s} \sum_{t \neq s} \frac{|z_{s}|^{2} + |z_{t}|^{2}}{(\lambda_{s} - \lambda_{t})^{2}} = 2 \sum_{s} |z_{s}|^{2} \sum_{t \neq s} \frac{1}{(\lambda_{s} - \lambda_{t})^{2}} $

The paper states that it is because it is due to the pair $(i,j)$ occuring once as $ s= i, t =j$ and once as $s=j, t=i$

I've tried plugging these in these values into the first sum but i don't see how the result follows.

Thank you.


Does this seem more clear? $$\sum_s \sum_{t \neq s} \frac{|z_s|^2 + |z_t|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2} = \sum_{(s,t)\\s \neq t} \frac{|z_s|^2 + |z_t|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2}$$ $$= \sum_{(s,t)\\s \neq t} \frac{|z_s|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2} + \sum_{(s,t)\\s \neq t} \frac{|z_t|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2} = 2 \sum_{(s,t)\\s \neq t} \frac{|z_s|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2}$$ $$= 2 \sum_s \sum_{t \neq s} \frac{|z_s|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2} = 2 \sum_s |z_s|^2 \sum_{t \neq s} \frac{1}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2}.$$

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks, i just had a couple of questions. 1): Does interchanging the index on the summation i.e. $ s \neq t $ and $t \neq s $ matter? 2): I'm not following how we get the first 2 if $ s \neq t$ ? $\endgroup$ – TKD Oct 8 '17 at 9:35
  • $\begingroup$ @TDK - Are you having trouble with the first equality? That summing over all possible $s$ and all possible $t$ such that $t \neq s$ is identical to summing over all possible pairs $(s,t)$ such that $s \neq t$? $\endgroup$ – John M Oct 10 '17 at 0:02
  • $\begingroup$ The step from $\sum_{(s,t)\\s \neq t} \frac{|z_s|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2} + \sum_{(s,t)\\s \neq t} \frac{|z_t|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2} = 2 \sum_{(s,t)\\s \neq t} \frac{|z_s|^2}{(\lambda_s - \lambda_t)^2}$ I'm not following where the "2" comes from if $ s \ne t $ $\endgroup$ – TKD Oct 10 '17 at 19:55
  • $\begingroup$ The two sums on the left hand side are identical. Just switch the labels $s$ and $t$ for one of those sums. $\endgroup$ – John M Oct 13 '17 at 21:14

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.