Let $X$ be a scheme. If $x\in X$ is a closed point, then it corresponds to a maximal ideal in $\mathcal{O}_X(U)$ for some affine open subset $U\subseteq X$.

If I take an arbitrary open affine $\mbox{Spec}~A$ in $X$ and a maximal ideal $x$ in $A$, then $\{x\}$ is closed in $\mbox{Spec}~A$, but may not be closed in $X$. It might even be the case that $\overline{\{x\}}$ contains a point belonging to an affine that has empty intersection with $\mbox{Spec}~A$.

Or not? Maybe I'm missing some easy topological property here.

Is there an example for such a situation? Or is it actually the case that $\{x\}$ will also be closed in $X$? If not, under what hypotheses on $X$ are all maximal ideals in the rings of affine opens also closed points in $X$?
Thank you in advance.


If $X=\mathrm{Spec}(A)$ is the spectrum of a discrete valuation ring, then the generic point $\eta$ is an affine open, namely $\mathrm{Spec}(k(\eta))$. Of course $\{\eta\}$ is closed in itself, but not in $\mathrm{Spec}(A)$. So this shows that a closed point in an affine open need not be closed in the ambient scheme.

This does, however, hold for schemes locally of finite type over a field $k$. Namely, if $X$ is such a $k$-scheme and $x\in X$ is closed in some affine open $\mathrm{Spec}(A)$, then $k(x)=A/\mathfrak{p}_x$ is an extension field of $k$ which is of finite type over $k$. So it is finite over $k$ by Zariski's lemma (also known sometimes as the Nullstellensatz). Now if $U=\mathrm{Spec}(B)$ is any affine open containing $x$, then $x$ corresponds to a prime $\mathfrak{p}_x^\prime$ of $B$, and $B/\mathfrak{p}_x^\prime$ is contained in $k(x)$ ($k(x)$ is the fraction field of this domain in fact). Since $k(x)/k$ is finite, we see that $B/\mathfrak{p}_x^\prime$ is a domain finite over a field, and so is itself a field, i.e., $\mathfrak{p}_x^\prime$ is a closed point of $\mathrm{Spec}(B)$. Since the affine opens cover $X$, it follows that $x$ is a closed point of $X$.

Perhaps there are other situations where closed points of affine opens are closed. I learned this particular fact from Qing Liu's book on algebraic geometry. If we're lucky maybe he will see this problem and add some further insight :)

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Even much worse situation can happen: there are schemes without closed points ! (While locally, any affine open subset $U$ has a closed point of $U$). An example is given in the book you refered to (Exercise 3.3.27). $\endgroup$ – user18119 Nov 22 '12 at 22:14

A counter-example(the same as the Keenan Kidwell's) Let $A$ be a discrete valuation ring. Let $m$ be its unique maximal ideal. Let $f$ be a generator of $m$. Then $A_f$ is the field of fractions of $A$. Hence $x = {0}$ is a closed point of $D(f) = Spec(A_f)$. But it is not closed in $Spec(A)$.

Proposition Let $A$ be a Jacobson ring. Let $X$ be a scheme of locally finite type over $A$. Let $x$ be a closed point of an open subset $U$ of $X$. Then $x$ is a closed point of $X$.

Proof: Let $\bar {\{x\}}$ be the closure of $\{x\}$ in $X$. Let $y \in \bar {\{x\}}$. It suffices to prove that $x = y$. Let $V = Spec(B)$ be an affine open neighborhood of $y$. Then $x \in V \cap U$. There exists an affine open subset $D(f) = Spec(B_f)$ such that $x \in D(f) \subset V \cap U$, where $f \in B$. Since $x$ is closed in $U$, $x$ is closed in $D(f)$. Hence $x$ is a maximal ideal of $B_f$. Since $B_f$ is finitely generated over $A$ and $A$ is a Jacobson ring, $x$ is a maximal ideal of $B$. Hence $x$ is closed in $V$. Hence $\bar {\{x\}}\cap V = \{x\}$. Hence $x = y$ as desired. QED

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ The converse is true: if any closed point of any affine open subset of $X$ is closed in $X$, then $X$ is a Jacobson scheme (EGA, IV$_3$, § 10.3-10,4). This means that for all affine open subsets $U$ of $X$, $O_X(U)$ is a Jacobson ring. $\endgroup$ – user18119 Nov 22 '12 at 22:09
  • $\begingroup$ @QiL I did not know that. Thanks for the input. $\endgroup$ – Makoto Kato Nov 22 '12 at 22:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.