I have the following function (from economics, the nested logit demand model).

$$ q_i(p)= \frac{\exp\left[\frac{\delta_i - bp_i}{\lambda}\right]\left(\sum_{j \in V_i}\exp\left[\frac{\delta_j - bp_j}{\lambda}\right]\right)^{\lambda-1}}{1 + \left(\sum_{j \in V_i}\exp\left[\frac{\delta_j - bp_j}{\lambda}\right]\right)^{\lambda} + \left(\sum_{l \in V_{-i}}\exp\left[\frac{\delta_l - bp_l}{\lambda}\right]\right)^{\lambda}} $$

$p$ and $\delta$ are vectors of length $I$, measuring the price and quality of each product $i$ according to the subscript. $V_i$ is set of products in the same group as product $i$, whilst $V_{-i}$ is all products in the other group (all products must fall in one group of the other). $b >0$ and $p_i > 0, \delta_i > 0, \forall i$, whilst $\lambda \in [0.5,1] $.

How do I find the three derivatives $\dfrac{\partial q_i(p)}{\partial p_i}$, $\dfrac{\partial q_i(p)}{\partial p_j}, j \in V_i$ and $\dfrac{\partial q_i(p)}{\partial p_k}, k \in V_{-i}$? I find it hard to compute this because the sums are raised to the power, and so it becomes very messy, although there may be a trick that makes this simpler.

up vote 3 down vote accepted

There is a trick involving decomposing the choice probability of a nested logit model. Have a look at Train 2009, Ch. 4 p. 86. In short, using Train's notation, the probability of individual $n$ choosing product $i$ in nest $B_k$ can be expressed as:

$P_{ni} = P_{ni | B_k} P_{n B_k}$

That is, the choice probability is the probability of choosing product $i$ given that nest $B_k$ is chosen times the probability of choosing nest $B_k$. These probabilities are (see derivation in the reference):

$P_{ni | B_k} = \dfrac{e^{Y_{ni}/\lambda_k}}{\sum_{j \in B_k} e^{Y_{ni}/\lambda_k} }$

$P_{nB_k} = \dfrac{e^{W_{nk} + \lambda_k I_{nk}}}{\sum^K_{l=1} e^{W_{nk} + \lambda_k I_{nk}}}$

where $I_{nk} = ln \sum_{j \in B_k} e^{Y_{nj}/\lambda_k}$ is the inclusive value from choosing nest $B_k$.

As you can see, these probabilities do not involve exponents over the summation terms, and finding price derivatives is now a much simpler exercise.

Your Answer


By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.