This question is a sort of continuation of this other question of mine Tricky inequality on norms of vectors .

Let $v_0,v_1,w_0,w_1\in \mathbb{R}^2$ be four non-zero vectors such that:

  • $v_0=(v_{0x},0)$, $v_1=(v_{1x},0)$ with $v_{0x}>0,v_{1x}>0$
  • $w_0=(w_{0x},w_{0y})$, $w_1=(w_{1x},w_{1y})$ with $w_{0y}\ge 0,w_{1y}\ge 0$
  • $\displaystyle{\frac{||v_1||}{||v_0||}> 1}$ and $\displaystyle{\frac{||v_1||}{||v_0||}> \max\{\frac{||w_1||}{||w_0||},\frac{||w_0||}{||w_1||}\}}$ and $\displaystyle{\frac{||v_1||}{||v_0||}> \max\{\frac{||v_1+w_1||}{||v_0+w_0||},\frac{||v_0+w_0||}{||v_1+w_1||}\}}$

Define $$v_t:=((1-t)v_{0x}+t*v_{1x},0),\quad w_t:=(1-t)w_0+t*w_1$$ for every $t\in [0,1]$.

Is it true that the following two inequalities

$$\frac{||v_{t_1}||}{||v_{t_0}||}\ge \max\{\frac{||w_{t_1}||}{||w_{t_0}||},\frac{||w_{t_0}||}{||w_{t_1}||}\} \quad \textit{and}\quad \frac{||v_{t_1}||}{||v_{t_0}||}\ge \max\{\frac{||v_{t_1}+w_{t_1}||}{||v_{t_0}+w_{t_0}||},\frac{||v_{t_0}+w_{t_0}||}{||w_{t_1}+w_{t_1}||}\}$$

are always satisfied for every $t_0,t_1\in [0,1]$, $t_0<t_1$?

I can't find any counterexample, but I either can't prove the claim


1 Answer 1


We construct a counterexample as follows. Put $w_0=(-1,1)$ and $w_1=(1,1)$. Then $$\|w_0\|=\|w_1\|=\sqrt{2},$$ so $$\frac{\|w_0\|}{\|w_1\|}=\frac{\|w_1\|}{\|w_0\|}=1.$$ But $$\|w_{1/2}\|=\| (1/2) w_0+(1/2) w_1\|=\|(0,1)\|=1.$$ Now take small positive numbers $\varepsilon$ and $\delta$ and put $v_{0x}=\varepsilon$ and $v_{1x}=\varepsilon(1+\delta)$. This satisfies two of the required inequalities. The third inequality transforms to

$$(1+\delta)^2>\frac{1+(1+\varepsilon)^2}{1+(1-\varepsilon(1+\delta))^2} $$

which is equivalent to


On the other hand, for every $t_0<t_1\in [0,1]$,

$$\frac{||v_{t_1}||}{||v_{t_0}||}=\frac{1+t_1\delta}{1+t_0\delta}\le 1+\delta.$$

Thus for a counterexample for the first asked inequality with $t_1=1/2$ and $t_0=1$ it suffices to take any (positive) $\delta<\sqrt{2}-1$ and $\varepsilon<\frac{\delta}{\sqrt{1+\delta^2}}$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.