Suppose that $\varphi,\gamma\in L^2([0,1],\mathbb C)$ and define the operator $\varphi\otimes\gamma:L^2([0,1],\mathbb C)\to L^2([0,1],\mathbb C)$ by setting $\varphi\otimes\gamma=\langle\cdot,\gamma\rangle\varphi$. This is an integral operator with the kernel given by $\varphi(x)\overline\gamma(y)$ for each $x,y\in [0,1]$. Hence, the Hilbert-Schmidt norm of this operator is given by $$ \|\varphi\otimes\gamma\|_{HS}=\biggl(\int_0^1\int_0^1|\varphi(x)\overline\gamma(y)|^2dxdy\biggr)^{1/2}=\|\varphi\|\|\gamma\|. $$ I want to find the singular values of this operator so that I can obtain the nuclear norm. Since the adjoint of $\varphi\otimes\gamma$ is given by $\gamma\otimes\varphi$, we have that $$ (\varphi\otimes\gamma)^*(\varphi\otimes\gamma)(f)=\langle f,\gamma\rangle\|\varphi\|^2\gamma $$ and if we set $f=\gamma/\|\gamma\|$, we obtain $$ (\varphi\otimes\gamma)^*(\varphi\otimes\gamma)(\gamma\|\gamma\|)=\|\varphi\|^2\|\gamma\|^2\gamma/\|\gamma\|. $$ The composition of operators $(\varphi\otimes\gamma)^*(\varphi\otimes\gamma)$ has one non-zero eigenfunction $\gamma/\|\gamma\|$ with the corresponding eigenvalue $\|\varphi\|^2\|\gamma\|^2$. Hence, the operator $\varphi\otimes\gamma$ has one non-zero singular value given by $\|\varphi\|\|\gamma\|$ and the nuclear norm of $\varphi\otimes\gamma$ is equal to $\|\varphi\|\|\gamma\|$, which is also the Hilbert-Schmidt of this operator.

Are my calculations correct? Does the composition of operators $(\varphi\otimes\gamma)^*(\varphi\otimes\gamma)$ have only one non-zero eigenfunction and the corresponding non-zero eigenvalue? Are the Hilbert-Schmidt and the nuclear norms really equal for this operator?

Any help is much appreciated!

  • $\begingroup$ Nuclear norm, is that the trace norm in this setting? $\endgroup$ – Jonas Dahlbæk Jun 26 '17 at 15:56
  • $\begingroup$ @JonasDahlbæk It is the Schatten norm with $p=1$ (see here for more details). $\endgroup$ – Cm7F7Bb Jun 27 '17 at 8:29

Yes. The operators $T=(\varphi\otimes\gamma)^*(\varphi\otimes\gamma) $ you are looking at, are rank one and positive. Concretely, you have that your operator is $$ Tf=\|\varphi\|^2\,\langle f,\gamma\rangle\,\gamma={\|\varphi\|^2}{\|\gamma\|^2}\,\langle f,\gamma'\rangle\,\gamma', $$ where $\gamma'=\gamma/\|\gamma\|$. Written this way, $T$ is a scalar multiple of the projection operator onto the span of $\gamma$. So its spectrum consists of $0$ and $\|\varphi\|^2\|\gamma\|^2$. So, for the HS norm, $$ \|\varphi\otimes\gamma\|_{\rm HS}^2=\text{Tr}\,((\varphi\otimes\gamma)^*(\varphi\otimes\gamma))^{1/2}=(0+\|\varphi\|^2\|\gamma\|^2)^{1/2}=\|\varphi\|\,\|\gamma\|. $$ For the operator norm, $$ \|\varphi\otimes\gamma\|=\|(\varphi\otimes\gamma)^*(\varphi\otimes\gamma)\|^{1/2}=\|\varphi\|\|\gamma\|. $$

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you very much (+1)! (1) How do we get that $Tf=\|\varphi\|^2\langle f,\gamma\rangle\gamma$? The operator is defined as $\varphi\otimes\gamma=\langle\cdot,\gamma\rangle\varphi$ and I get $Tf=\langle f,\gamma\rangle\varphi$. (2) I think the HS norm does not need to be squared here. (3) For this operator, actually all Schatten norms (for each $1\le p\le \infty$) are equal to its non-zero singular value, right? $\endgroup$ – Cm7F7Bb Jun 27 '17 at 8:48
  • $\begingroup$ What I call $T $ is $(\varphi\otimes\gamma)^*(\varphi\otimes\gamma) $. $\endgroup$ – Martin Argerami Jun 27 '17 at 13:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.