Take a group $G$ of order $\lvert G \rvert = 68 = 2^2\cdot17$. Let $n_2$ be the number of $2$-Sylow Subgroups of $G$ and $n_{17}$ be the number of $17$-Sylow Subgroups of $G$. Since $\lvert G \rvert = 2^2\cdot17$, we have

\begin{align} n_2\vert17\ \ \ &\text{and}\ \ \ n_2 \equiv 1\mod{2}\\ n_{17}\vert 4\ \ \ &\text{and}\ \ \ n_{17}\equiv 1 \mod{17} \end{align}

Since the only $n_{17}$ that divides $4$ which is also congruent to $1$ modulo $17$ is $1$, we must have that $n_{17} = 1$, while for $n_2$ we have that $n_2 = 1, 17$.

I'm confused, though, that $n_2$ could be equal to $17$, because $G$ must have a subgroup of order $17$, but if $n_2 = 17$ then we have $17$ subgroups of $G$ each of order $4$, which leaves no room for a subgroup of order $17.$

Have I made a silly mistake/is my understanding off?


$17$ subgroups of order $4$ at least all intersect in the identity. So that means they consist together of at most $$1+17(4-1)=52$$ elements. Now we've already accounted for the identity, so a subgroup of order $17$ only adds $16$ more elements, which adds up to $68$.

In general, the subgroups of order $4$ could share more elements than just the identity, so their union would have even fewer than $52$ elements.

  • $\begingroup$ Of course, I was counting the identity 17 times. Thanks. $\endgroup$ – ÍgjøgnumMeg Jun 18 '17 at 15:25
  • $\begingroup$ @Ig No problem. $\endgroup$ – Matt Samuel Jun 18 '17 at 15:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.