I have a question about Sobolev spaces.

I am reading A First Course in Sobolev Spaces by Giovanni Leoni. In this book, a sufficient and necessary condition is stated (Exercise 11.18):

Let $\Omega \subset \mathbb{R}^d$ be an open subset and let $1 \le p <\infty$. The embedding \begin{equation*} W^{1,p}(\Omega) \to L^{p}(\Omega) \end{equation*} is compact if and only if \begin{equation*} \lim_{n \to \infty} \sup \left\{ \int_{\Omega \setminus \Omega_n}|u|^p\,dx :\|u\|_{W^{1,p}(\Omega)} \le 1 \right\}=0, \end{equation*} where $\Omega_n=\left\{x \in \Omega: \text{dist}(x,\partial \Omega)>1/n, |x|<n \right\}$.

I would like to know the solution of this exercise. If you know references and papers related to this exercise, please let me know.

Thanks in advance.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ This could help. $\endgroup$ – Daniel Fischer May 31 '17 at 11:50
  • $\begingroup$ Thank you for your reply. This theorem seems to related to my question. $\endgroup$ – sharpe May 31 '17 at 12:25
  • Case $1 \le p < N$: let $\{u_n\} \subset B_{W^{1,p}(\Omega)}(0,1)$, we need to show that there exist a subsequence $\{u_{n_k}\}$ and a function $u \in L^p(\Omega)$ such that $u_{n_k} \to u$ in $L^p(\Omega)$. The main difficulty is that we cannot apply directly the Rellich-Kondrachov Theorem since we don't have any information about the regularity of the domain $\Omega$. Here is a way to around this problem:

Fact: (I'll leave this as an exercise -insert diabolic laughter-) Let $B$ be an open set and let $A \subset B$ such that $\text{dist}(A,\partial B) \ge \eta$, for some fiven $\eta > 0$. Then There exists an open set $C$ of class $C^1$ such that $A \subset C \subset B$ and $\text{dist}(C,\partial B) > \eta/2.$

Consider $\Omega_1 \subset \Omega$ as in the statement of the problem and find $U_1$ open and of class $C^1$ as above. Applying the RKT to $\{u_n\}$ restricted to $U_1$ we can find a subsequence $\{u_n^1\} \subset \{u_n\}$ and $u^1 \in L^p(U_1)$ such that $u_n^1 \to u^1$ in $L^p(U_1)$. Now consider $\Omega_2$ and find $U_2$ as above. Then you can apply the RKT in $U_2$ to $\{u_n^1\}$ to get a further subsequence $\{u_n^2\}$ and a function $u^2$ such that $u_n^2 \to u^2$ in $L^p(U_2)$. Notice that by uniqueness of the weak limit, $u^1 = u^2$ a.e. in $U_1 \cap U_2$. By a standard diagonal procedure, $v_n = u_n^n$ converges to a function $u$ in $L^p(u_n)$ for every $n$. $$ \begin{align} \|v_n - u\|_{L^p(\Omega)} = &\ \|v_n - u\|_{L^p(\Omega_n)} + \|v_n - u\|_{L^p(\Omega \setminus \Omega_n)} \\ \le &\ \|v_n - u\|_{L^p(U_n)} + \|v_n\|_{L^p(\Omega \setminus \Omega_n)} + \|u\|_{L^p(\Omega \setminus \Omega_n)} \\ \to &\ 0 \ \text{as } n \to \infty. \end{align} $$

  • Case $p > N$: I'll show the result for a regular bounded domain $U$, the conclusion then follows by a diagonal argument exactly as above.

We have the following facts, which again I'll leave for you to check:

  1. $W^{1,p}(U) \hookrightarrow C^{0,1-\frac{N}{p}}(\bar{U})$.
  2. $C^{0,1-\frac{N}{p}}(\bar{U}) \hookrightarrow \hookrightarrow C^{0,\alpha}(\bar{U})$ for every $0 < \alpha < 1 - \frac{N}{p}$.
  3. $C^{0,\alpha}(\bar{U}) \hookrightarrow L^p(U)$.

Since the composition of a compact operator with a continuous operator is compact the result follows by combining the embeddings in 1,2,3.

  • Case $p = N$: As in the previous case, let $U$ be a bounded regular domain (the diagonal argument can then be applied). For $q < N$ we have $$W^{1,N}(U) \hookrightarrow W^{1,q}(U) \hookrightarrow\hookrightarrow L^s(U), \quad s < q^*.$$ To conclude the proof it is enough to notice that for $q > \frac{N}{2}$, $q^* > N$.

Proof of necessity: assume by contradiction that $$\limsup_{n \to \infty} \sup_{u \in B(0,1)}\int_{\Omega \setminus \Omega_n}|u|^p = \eta > 0.$$ Then we can find $\bar{n}$ and $\{u_n\}$ such that if $n \ge \bar{n}$ $$\int_{\Omega \setminus \Omega_n}|u_n|^p \ge \frac{\eta}{2}.$$ By assumption $W^{1,p}(\Omega) \hookrightarrow \hookrightarrow L^p(\Omega)$ then $\{u_n\}$ has subsequence (not relabeled) that converges. To get a contradiction we can show that this subsequence is not Cauchy.

To this end, fix $n$ and consider $u_n \cdot \chi_{\Omega \setminus \Omega_m}$. By Lebesgue's Dominated Convergence Theorem, $u_n \cdot \chi_{\Omega \setminus \Omega_m} \to 0$ in $L^p$ as $m \to \infty$. Then there exists $\bar{m}$ such that if $m \ge \bar{m}$ $$\int_{\Omega \setminus \Omega_m}|u_n|^p \le \frac{\eta}{4}.$$ Then for $m,n$ large we have $$ \begin{align} \|u_n - u_m\|_{L^p(\Omega)} \ge &\ \|u_n - u_m\|_{L^p(\Omega \setminus \Omega_m)} \\ \ge &\ \|u_m\|_{L^p(\Omega \setminus \Omega_m)} - \|u_n\|_{L^p(\Omega \setminus \Omega_m)} \\ \ge &\ \frac{\eta}{2} - \frac{\eta}{4} = \frac{\eta}{4} > 0. \end{align} $$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.