0
$\begingroup$

So I seem to be reaching 2 seemingly distinct answers when evaluating the following integral with two approaches:

$$ \int{\cot(10z)\csc^4(10z)}\;dz $$

In the first approach, I break $\csc^4(10z)$ up into $\csc^2(10z)\csc^2(10z)$ and substitute in $\csc^2(10z) = \cot^2(10z) + 1$ for one of them, like so:

$$ \int{\cot(10z)(\cot^2(10z) + 1)\csc^2(10z)}\;dz $$

Then, I u-substitute in $ u = \cot(10z) $ and $ du = -10\csc^2(10z)\;dz $ to get

$$ {-\frac{1}{10}\int{u(u^2 + 1)}\;du} $$ $$ = {-\frac{1}{10}\int{u^3 + u}\;du} $$ $$ = -\frac{u^4}{40} - \frac{u^2}{20} + C $$ $$ = \bbox[yellow,5px,border:2px solid red]{-\frac{\cot^4(10z)}{40} - \frac{\cot^2(10z)}{20} + C} \tag{1} $$

It seems like a completely legitimate approach to me. However, if I use another technique where I break $ \csc^4(10z) $ up into $ \csc^3(10z)\csc(10z) $ instead, and then u-substitute $ u = \csc(10z) $ with $ -\frac{du}{10} = \csc(10z)\cot(10z)\;dz $, I get

$$ {-\frac{1}{10}\int{u^3}\;du} $$ $$ = \bbox[yellow,5px,border:2px solid red]{-\frac{\csc^4(10z)}{40} + C} \tag{2} $$

Now, these are apparently not equal as plugging in $ z = 1 $ results in about $ -0.2604 $ for $ (1) $ and $ -0.2854 $ for $ (2) $. What is going on here? Why am I reaching this contradiction?

Improve this question
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ The first sanity check is to set $C=0$ in both and plug in a few independent values of $z$ to see if they both differ by the same constant every time $\endgroup$ – user14972 Apr 17 '17 at 3:35
  • $\begingroup$ Try to use $k$ as constant in the first and use the identity $csc^2x=1+\cot^2x$ $\endgroup$ – Juniven Apr 17 '17 at 3:37
  • $\begingroup$ Just checking one value isn't enough to establish that they are different. The solution isn't 1 function, but a set of functions. $\endgroup$ – DanielV Apr 17 '17 at 5:32
  • $\begingroup$ @DanielV Here you can clearly see that $(1)$ and $(2)$ differ by only a constant $(0.025)$, and as such evaluating the indefinite integrals with any two limits, the same ones for both, you can see that $\int{(1)(x)} = \int{(2)(x)}$. Interesting. $\endgroup$ – R. Kap Apr 17 '17 at 6:09
0
$\begingroup$

Taking your first answer,

$\frac{-\cot^2(10z)}{40} \left[\cot^2(10z)+2 \right] + c$

$\frac{-\cot^2(10z)}{40} \left[\csc^2(10z)-1+2 \right] + c$

$\frac{-\cot^2(10z)}{40} \left[\cot^2(10z)+1 \right] + c$

$\frac{1-\csc^2(10z)}{40} \left[1+\cot^2(10z) \right] + c$

$\frac{1 - \csc^4(10z)}{40} + c$

$\frac{1}{40} - \frac {\csc^4(10z)}{40} + c$

$\frac{- \csc^4(10z)}{40} + c'$

Improve this answer
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.