I am working with the book Introduction to Tropical Geometry by Sturmfels and Maclagan, and am trying to understand Kapranov's Theorem (Theorem 3.1.3 in the book), which states (I only mention the relevant parts): $\newcommand{\u}{\textbf{u}} \newcommand{\w}{\textbf{w}}$

Let $K$ be algebraically closed field with a non-trivial valuation $\text{val}: K \to \mathbb{R} \cup \infty$.

Fix a Laurent polynomial $f = \sum_{\u \in \mathbb{Z}^n}{c_{\u}x^\u}$ in $K[x_1^{\pm1},\dots, x_n^{\pm1}]$. The following sets coincide:

(1) the tropical hypersurface $\text{trop}(V(f))$

(2) the closure in $\mathbb{R}^n$ of the set $\{\w \in \Gamma^n_{\text{val}} : \text{in}_\w(f) \text{ is not a monomial } \}$

(3) ...

Here $\Gamma_\text{val}$ denotes the value group which is dense in $\mathbb{R}$, and $\text{in}_\w(f)$ is the initial form with respect to vector $\w$. Topology on $\mathbb R^n$ is the Euclidean topology.

Then the book says without explanation:

Note that the closure in Set 2 equals $\{\w \in \mathbb R^n : \text{in}_\w(f) \text{ is not a monomial } \}$

This is something I don't understand (although I know that the value group is dense in $\mathbb{R}$, so the closure of $\Gamma_\text{val}^n$ is $\mathbb R ^n $).

Could someone explain to me why this set is exactly the closure?

Thanks a lot!

  • This seems to be equivalent to showing $\{\w \in \mathbb R^n : \text{in}_\w(f) \text{ is not a monomial } \}$ is closed. It surely is necessary; and if it's true then closure of intersection with a dense set is the set itself. – Max Apr 5 '17 at 21:02
  • On the other hand $\{\w \in \mathbb R^n : \text{in}_\w(f) \text{ is not a monomial } \}$ is closed as finite union (over all pairs of monomial exponents $u$ with non zero $c_u$) of closed sets $K_{ij}$ of $w$s for which $f(u)=val(c_u)+w\cdot u$ has $f(u_i)=f(u_j)$ (linear equation) and this is $\leq f(u_k)$ for all other $u_k$ (finite set of non-strict linear inequalities). – Max Apr 5 '17 at 21:36
up vote 0 down vote accepted

$\def\valgroup{\Gamma_{\text{val}}} \def\trop{\text{trop}} \def\Z{{\mathbb Z}} \def\Q{{\mathbb Q}} \def\R{{\mathbb R}} \newcommand{\val}[1]{\text{val}(#1)} \newcommand{\vect}[1]{\text{\bf #1}}$

I will answer this myself. Maybe it will help someone sometime. Here is a detailed proof:

We want to show that the closure $\bar A$ with regard to the Euclidean topology (let $\langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle$ denote inner product) of the set $A := \{ w \in \valgroup^n : \text{in}_{w}(f) \text{ is not a monomial} \}$ is $$\bar A = B := \{ w \in \R^n : \text{in}_{w}(f) \text{ is not a monomial} \}$$

As $K$ is algebraically closed and its valuation is non-trivial, we know that $\valgroup$ is dense in $\R$. Thus every open subset in $B$ contains a point in $A$, and we have $B \subset \bar A$. So it remains to show that $B$ is closed, i.e. show that $\R^n \setminus B = \{ w \in \R^n : \text{in}_{w}(f) \text{ is a monomial} \} =: C$ is open.

Let $w \in C$. Then the minimum in $$\trop(f)(w) = \underset{u \in \Z^n : c_{u} \neq 0 }{\min}\{ \val{c_u} + \langle u, w \rangle \}$$ is achieved only once, i.e. $\exists v \in \Z^n$ such that $c_v \neq 0$ and $\forall u \neq v$ we have $\val{c_v} + \langle v, w \rangle < \val{c_u} + \langle u, w \rangle$.

So, given any $u \in \Z^n$ with $c_u \neq 0$, define the oviously continuous function $$g_u : \R^n \to \R, x \mapsto \val{c_u} + \langle u, x \rangle$$

Let $U := \{u \in \Z^n : c_{u} \neq 0 \}$ which is finite. Have $g_{v}(w) < g_{u}(w) \ \forall u \in U \setminus \{v\}$. Set $\epsilon := \underset{u \in U \setminus \{ v \} }{\min}\{g_u(w) - g_v(w)\} > 0$. Because of continuity $\forall u \in U$ get $\delta_u > 0$ s.t. $\lvert g_u(w) - g_u(\tilde w) \rvert < \frac{\epsilon}{2} \ \forall \tilde w$ in the open ball $B_{\delta_u}(w)$ around $w$. Set $\delta := \underset{u \in U}{\min}\{\delta_u\}$ and let $x \in B_\delta(w)$.

Then $\forall u \in U \setminus \{v\}$ we have

\begin{equation*} \begin{split} \underbrace{g_u(x)}_{> g_u(w) - \frac{\epsilon}{2}} - \underbrace{g_v(x)}_{< g_v(w) + \frac{\epsilon}{2}} > g_u(w) - \frac{\epsilon}{2} - g_v(w) - \frac{\epsilon}{2} \underset{g_u(w) - g_v(w) \geq \epsilon}{\geq} \epsilon - \epsilon = 0 \end{split} \end{equation*}

Thus the minimum in $\trop(f)(x)$ is also achieved only once and $\text{in}_x(f)$ is monomial $\implies B_\delta(w) \subset C \implies C \text{ open } \implies B \text{ closed}$.

Your Answer


By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.