let $a>2$ be a constant. If there are just 18 positive integers satisfying the inequality $(x-a)(x-2a)(x-a^2)<0$ then find the natural number $a$.

zeroes: $a\ \ \ \ \ \ \ 2a\ \ \ \ \ \ \ a^2$
$\ \ -ve\ \ +ve\ \ \ -ve\ \ \ \ +ve$

Set of solutions:$\{ 3,4,5,\cdots, a-1\}U\{2a+1,2a+2,\cdots,a^2-1\}$

No. of elements =18

But this equation has no solution in natural numbers.

What fault have I made in my procedure?


You already wrote that the zeroes are $a$, $2a$ and $a^2$.

Next, you need to check that the equation is true for $x<a$ and for $2a<x<a^2$ since $a$ is a natural number.

Since you only consider positive integers, you also have $x>0$.

There are $a-1$ positive integers between $0$ and $a$, and $a^2-2a-1$ positive integers between $2a$ and $a^2$.

In total, we have $$a^2-2a-1+a-1=a^2-a-2$$ positive integers satisfying your equation. Finally, we solve $a^2-a-2=18$ and find out that $a=5$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.