For which cardinalities $\kappa$ is $\def\Q{\mathbb Q}\Q^{(\kappa)}$—by which I mean the direct sum of $\kappa$-many copies of $\Q$—isomorphic (as an abelian group) to the multiplicative group of units of some field $F$?

$\Q^{(\kappa)}$ is torsion-free, so for example we can see that the characteristic of $F$ must be 2: since $(-1)^2 = 1$, it is torsion unless $-1 = 1$. $\Q^{(\kappa)}$ is also a divisible group.

From a paper cited in this answer to a previous question of mine, we know that:

  • $\kappa = 0$ works: $\Q^{(0)} \cong (\Bbb Z/2\Bbb Z)^*$,
  • $\kappa = 1$ doesn't work: everything has to be algebraic over $\Bbb Z/2\Bbb Z$ and hence torsion,
  • Some uncountable $\kappa$ works: we can show the following ultraproduct has multiplicative group isomorphic to $\Q^{\aleph_0} \cong \Q^{(\kappa)}$: $$F = \prod_{p\ \text{prime}} \mathrm{GF}(2^p)/U.$$ I think that saying $\kappa = 2^{\aleph_0}$ is assuming CH but whatever.

Are there any other $\kappa$, especially finite, for which we can answer yes or no?


There is no such field $ F $ for finite $ \kappa $. As you observed, if such a field exists, it must have characteristic $ 2 $. Furthermore, it cannot contain any elements which are algebraic over its prime field $ \mathbb F_2 $ (besides those that are already in $ \mathbb F_2 $), because then $ F^{\times} $ has torsion, which is a contradiction. Since $ F \neq \mathbb F_2 $, it follows that there's an embedding $ \mathbb F_2(T) \to F $, which gives an embedding of multiplicative groups $ \mathbb F_2(T)^{\times} \to F^{\times} \cong \mathbb Q^{\kappa} $. $ \mathbb F_2(T)^{\times} \cong \mathbb Z^{\omega} $, thus it suffices to show that there is no embedding $ \mathbb Z^{\omega} \to \mathbb Q^{\kappa} $ for $ \kappa $ finite. This follows, since the image of $ n $ $ \mathbb Z $-linearly independent elements in $ \mathbb Z^{\omega} $ is linearly independent in $ \mathbb Q^{\kappa} $, thus $ \kappa > n $ for all natural numbers $ n $, i.e $ \kappa $ must be infinite.

  • $\begingroup$ Excellent! I think that this plus Lowenheim-Skolem (fields with torsion-free divisible multiplicative groups is first-order) tells us that every infinite $\kappa$ works and the only finite one that does is 0. $\endgroup$ – algorithmshark Feb 6 '17 at 19:02

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.