Earlier today I asked this question: Derivative of Function with Cases: $f(x)=x^2\sin x^{-1}$ for $x\ne0$

Following the answers to my question I worked on my problem. Among other things I showed that the left hand limit of the derivative of the function from the question is equal to the left hand derivative. But that lead me to a new question:

A function is differentiable in $x$ iff $f'_+(x) = f'_-(x)$. But also a function isn't differentiable in $x$ if it is not continuous in $x$. What if both things are true?

The function $$f(x) = \begin{cases}x^2\sin x^{-1} & \text{if } x \neq 0\\ 10 & \text{else }\end{cases}$$ for instance. Here the right hand derivative is equal to the left hand derivative:

from the left:

\begin{align*} \lim_{x \to 0^-} \frac{f(x) - f(0)}{x - 0} & = \lim_{x \to 0^-} \frac{x^2 \sin \left( \frac{1}{x} \right) - {0^2 \sin \left( \frac{1}{0} \right)}}{x - 0}\\ & = \lim_{x \to 0^-} \frac{{x} \left(x\sin \left( \frac{1}{x} \right) \right)}{{x}}\\ & = \lim_{x \to 0^-} \frac{{x\sin \left( \frac{1}{x} \right)}}{1}\\ & = 0 \end{align*}

from the right:

\begin{align*} \lim_{x \to 0^+} \frac{f(x) - f(0)}{x - 0} & = \lim_{x \to 0^+} \frac{x^2 \sin \left( \frac{1}{x} \right) - {0^2 \sin \left( \frac{1}{0} \right)}}{x - 0}\\ & = \lim_{x \to 0^+} \frac{{x} \left(x\sin \left( \frac{1}{x} \right) \right)}{{x}}\\ & = \lim_{x \to 0^+} \frac{{x\sin \left( \frac{1}{x} \right)}}{1}\\ & = 0 \end{align*}

So, as the left and right hand limits are the same $f$ must be differentiable in $0$, right? But it is obviously not continuous at $0$, as $f(0) = 10$ but $\lim_{x \to 0} f(x) = 0$, so then it must not be differentiable... What am I missing here? Is the left-right-hand limit equality just a necessary rather than a sufficient precondition for differentiability?

  • 4
    $\begingroup$ What you're missing is that $f(x) - f(0) = f(x) - 10$. $\endgroup$ – user384138 Jan 14 '17 at 8:03
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ $f(0)$ is $10$ and not $(0^2 \sin \left( \frac{1}{0} \right))$ according to your definition of $f$. Besides that the latter expressiond does not make sense because of $\frac{1}{0}$. $\endgroup$ – miracle173 Jan 14 '17 at 8:07
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @user3578468 It's not relevant. The definition of $f$ says that when $x = 0$, $f(x) = 10$, no matter what expression $f$ has otherwise. The limit of $f$ as $x \to 0$ is $0$, because $x^2$ pushes it to $0$, but the value at $0$ is $10$. $\endgroup$ – Arthur Jan 14 '17 at 8:20
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ You're investigating the derivative at $0$, and part of that involves evaluating $f$ exactly at $0$. $\endgroup$ – Arthur Jan 14 '17 at 9:04
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ You can look at the definition of $f'(0)$, which is $\lim_{h \to 0}\frac{f(h) - f(0)}{h}$. You see the $f(0)$ in there? That's not a limit, that's actually $f(0)$. How can you convince yourself of that? Because that's what it says. If we had meant something else, we would've written something else. $\endgroup$ – Arthur Jan 14 '17 at 9:09

1.There is no real number $\frac {1}{0}.$ Any computations using it are false or meaningless.

  1. If $f(x)=x^2 \sin 1/x$ for $x>0$ and $f(x)=10$ for $x\leq 0$ then for $x>0$ we have $$\frac {f(x)-f(0)}{x-0}=\frac {x^2\sin 1/x -10}{x}=x(\sin 1/x) -10/x $$which has no limit as $x\to 0.$ So $f$ has no "upper" derivative at $0.$
| cite | improve this answer | |
  • $\begingroup$ What do you mean by that? $\lim_{x \to 0} \frac{x \sin \frac{1}{x} - 10}{x} = \lim_{x \to 0} \frac{x \sin \frac{1}{x}}{x} - \lim_{x \to 0} \frac{10}{x} = 0 -\infty$ $\endgroup$ – user3578468 Jan 14 '17 at 9:19
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Infinity is not a real number either. When we say that something goes to infinity, it is a euphemism for a longer rigorous statement. And $ \lim_{x\to \infty}f(x)=y$ is a short form for a longer rigorous statement that is meaningful only when $y\in \mathbb R.$ $\endgroup$ – DanielWainfleet Jan 14 '17 at 10:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.