1
$\begingroup$

A many population $U$ has many elements $u_i$, each of which has some associated value of interest $x_i$ which can be measured precisely. The values of $x$ are distributed according to a Gaussian distribution. For the purposes of this question, it can be assumed that this is a unit normal distribution because the answer to the question will not depend on the underlying mean or variance.

Two experimenters, $E_1$ and $E_2$, are interested in determining the population mean value $<x>$. $E_1$ obtains $n>1$ samples from $U$, computes the mean, and computes a 95% confidence interval, of length $I_1$ centered on that estimated mean. $I_1$ is of course proportional to the standard error of the sample that $Ee_1$ obtained.

$E_2$ does exactly the same experiment as $E_1$, except that she uses twice the sample size: $2n$ samples. It is, of course, likely that $I_2 < I_1$, but that is not certain.

What is the probability $A(n)$ that $I_1 < I_2$?

That is meant to ask how rapidly does $A(n)$ fall with $n$.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Suppose $E_1$ gets sample variance $S_2^2$ and $E_2$ gets $S_2^2,$ then it seems you are asking for $P(S_1^2/n < S_2^2/2n) =$ $P(\frac{S_1^2/n}{S_2^2/2n} < 1),$ where $S_1^2/S_2^2 \sim F(n-1,2n-1).$ $\endgroup$ – BruceET Jan 11 '17 at 18:45
  • $\begingroup$ Small adjustment necessary to compare CI lengths instead of std errors. $\endgroup$ – BruceET Jan 11 '17 at 22:39
1
$\begingroup$

$E_1$ computes a CI with half-width $I_1/2 = t_{\alpha}(n-1)S_{n}/\sqrt{n}$

$E_2$ computes a CI with half-width $I_2/2= t_{\alpha}(2n-1)S_{2n}/\sqrt{2n}$

where $S_k$ is the usual unbiased standard deviation for the sample of size $k$, and $t_\alpha(d)$ denotes the critical value for a $t$-distribution with $d$ degrees of freedom.

By Cochran's theorem, $$(n-1)\frac{S_n^2}{\sigma^2}\sim\chi^2_{n-1}\\ (2n-1)\frac{S_{2n}^2}{\sigma^2}\sim\chi^2_{2n-1} $$ so (assuming the samples are independent) $$\frac{S_n^2}{S_{2n}^2}\sim \frac{\chi^2_{n-1}/(n-1)}{\chi^2_{2n-1}/(2n-1)}\sim F_{n-1,2n-1} $$ where $F_{d_1,d_2}$ denotes a random variable with an F-distribution with $d_1$ and $d_2$ degrees of freedom. Then $$\begin{align}P(I_1<I_2) &= P(t_{\alpha}(n-1)S_{n}/\sqrt{n}< t_{\alpha}(2n-1)S_{2n}/\sqrt{2n})\\ &=P(\frac{S_{n}}{S_{2n}}< \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\frac{t_{\alpha}(2n-1)}{t_{\alpha}(n-1)})\\ &=P\left(\frac{S_{n}^2}{S_{2n}^2}< \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{t_{\alpha}(2n-1)}{t_{\alpha}(n-1)}\right)^2\right)\\ &=P\left(F_{n-1,2n-1}<\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{t_{\alpha}(2n-1)}{t_{\alpha}(n-1)}\right)^2\right)\end{align}.$$

| cite | improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Looks right (+1). My answer focused just on std err, not length of CI. For $n > 30$ and 95% CIs, the critical values of t are all about 2.0, so it doesn't make much difference. After lunch, I plan to adjust my answer. $\endgroup$ – BruceET Jan 11 '17 at 19:29
  • $\begingroup$ Adjustment made for 99% CIs, where it makes enough difference to notice for small $n$. Asymptotically, negligible. $\endgroup$ – BruceET Jan 11 '17 at 22:36
1
$\begingroup$

If $S^2_n$ denotes the sample variance obtained from a sample of size $n$, then $$P(I_2> I_1)=P\left(\frac{S^2_{2n}}{2n}>\frac{S^2_{n}}{n}\right)=P(S^2_{2n}>2S^2_n).\tag1$$ Since $S_n^2$ is distributed like $\frac1{n-1}\sum_1^{n-1}Y_i^2$ where $Y_1,Y_2,\ldots,Y_{n-1}$ are iid standard normal, the desired probability can be written $$ P\left(\frac1{2n-1}\sum_1^{2n-1} Y_i^2 > 2\frac1{n-1}\sum_1^{n-1}Y'^{2}_j\right)\tag2 $$ where the $Y_i$'s and $Y'_j$'s are mutually independent standard normal. Noting that each $Y^2$ has mean $\sigma^2=1$ and variance $2\sigma^4$, we can further manipulate (2) to obtain $$ P\left(\frac{\sqrt n}{\sqrt{2n-1}}\frac{\sum(Y_i-\sigma^2)}{\sqrt{(2n-1)2\sigma^4}}-2\frac{\sqrt n}{\sqrt{n-1}}\frac{\sum(Y'^{2}_j-\sigma^2)}{\sqrt{(n-1)2\sigma^4}} > \sqrt{2n}\right).\tag3 $$ Now by the central limit theorem the LHS of the inequality in (3) is approximately distributed like $ \frac1{\sqrt 2}X -2X' $, where $X$ and $X'$ are independent standard normal. So (3) is approximately the gaussian tail probability $$P(Z>\frac23\sqrt n)\le k\frac {e^{-2n/9}}{\sqrt n},\tag4$$ which I've bounded using this upper-tail inequality.

(Please check my algebra throughout.)

| cite | improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ As mentioned in the Answer of @r.e.s., your first equality in (1) is not strictly true, but the adjustment to correct for that is small; (+1) anyway. $\endgroup$ – BruceET Jan 11 '17 at 19:33
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @BruceET You are right, the critical value for $n$ differs from that for $2n$. Luckily the required adjustment washes out asymptotically. $\endgroup$ – grand_chat Jan 11 '17 at 19:40
1
$\begingroup$

Following my Comments and using lengths of 99% CIs instead of standard errors. I used 99% CIs instead of 95% CIs because the necessary correction is a little larger, and especially more noticeable for small $n.$

n=2:60; t1 = qt(.995,n-1);  t2 = qt(.995, 2*n -1)
a = pf(.5*(t2/t1)^2, n-1, 2*n-1)
plot(n, a, ylim=c(0,.11), pch=20)
abline(h=0, col="green2")

enter image description here

Reality check: In the above $A(20) = 0.0316.$ Do the simulation with $m = 100,000$ iterations for each experimenter and compare lengths of their 99% CIs:

m = 10^5;  n = 20;  q1 = qt(.995, 9);  q2 = qt(.995, 19)
MAT1 = matrix(rnorm(m*n), nrow=m)
MAT2 = matrix(rnorm(m*n*2), nrow=m)
len1 = 2*q1*apply(MAT1, 1, sd)/sqrt(n)
len2 = 2*q2*apply(MAT2, 1, sd)/sqrt(2*n)
mean(len1 < len2)
## 0.03144                # aprx A(20)
pf(.5*(q2/q1)^2, n-1, 2*n-1)
## 0.03158697             # exact A(20)
| cite | improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.