The Milnor-Moore theorem states that for path-connected H-spaces $X$, $H_*(X;\Bbb Q)$ is a free graded-commutative algebra on $\pi_*(X)\otimes \Bbb Q$. I am asked to use this to compute $\pi_i(S^n)\otimes \Bbb Q$.

I know another way of computing $\pi_i(S^n)\otimes \Bbb Q$ which does not use the Milnor-Moore theorem. I'm not sure how one would use this theorem since the only spheres which are H-spaces are in dimensions 1,3 and 7.

  • $\begingroup$ Or consider the $H$-space $\Omega S^n$. $\endgroup$ – Justin Young Jan 15 '17 at 21:00
  • $\begingroup$ Indeed $\Omega S^n$ works, I wish I could delete the question now. $\endgroup$ – iwriteonbananas Jan 16 '17 at 8:51
  • $\begingroup$ Not sure I agree with the statement of the Milnor-Moore theorem, though. I think you get the universal enveloping algebra, which should not be the same as the free commuative algebra. $\endgroup$ – Justin Young Jan 19 '17 at 15:58
  • $\begingroup$ Or maybe you mean cohomology? $\endgroup$ – Justin Young Jan 20 '17 at 11:36
  • $\begingroup$ Hm, no I mean homology @JustinYoung, but I agree, I think there is a mistake in the statement of the theorem. $\endgroup$ – iwriteonbananas Jan 20 '17 at 12:38

I thought I would post an answer anyway since it's a nice problem. The Milnor-Moore theorem (in this context) states that if $X$ is a path-connected $H$-space then $H_*(X) = U(\pi_*(X)\otimes \mathbb Q)$ is isomorphic as a Hopf algebra to the universal enveloping algebra over the Lie algebra $\pi_*(X)\otimes \mathbb Q$ (the Lie bracket is the Whitehead product, and the inclusion of the primitives is induced by the Hurewicz map). Applying this to $X =\Omega S^n$ for $n\ge 2$ we calculate (using spectral sequences for example) that $H_*(X) = \mathbb Q[x]$ as an algebra on a class $x$ in degree $n-1$. For degree reasons, $x$ is primitive. Using the Hopf algebra property we get that $\Delta (x^k)$ is a signed sum of terms of the form $x^i \otimes x^j$ where $i+j = k$.

If $n$ is odd, then $n-1$ is even and therefore $x^k$ is not primitive for $k>1$.

But if $n$ is even, then $n-1$ is odd and we get $\Delta(x^2) = 1\otimes x^2 + x^2 \otimes 1$, the middle terms cancel. For $k>2$, we have $\Delta(x^k) = \Delta(x^2 x^{k-2}) = \Delta(x^2) \Delta(x^{k-2})$, since $x^2$ has even degree, none of the terms cancel, and so we have, at least, a nonzero term of the form $\alpha x^2 \otimes x^{k-2}$. It follows that $x^k$ is not primitive for $k>2$.

Thus, the primitive Lie algebra is just $x$ in degree $n-1$ for $n$ odd and $x, x^2$ in degrees $n-1$ and $2(n-1)$ for $n$ even. Since the Lie algebra is also $\pi_*(\Omega S^n)\otimes \mathbb Q = \pi_{*+1}(S^n)\otimes \mathbb Q$, we get the standard result.

For $n$ odd $\pi_*(S^n)\otimes \mathbb Q = \mathbb Q$ for $* = n$ and zero otherwise.

For $n$ even $\pi_*(S^n)\otimes \mathbb Q = \mathbb Q$ for $* = n, 2n-1$ and zero otherwise.


Indeed, you can only use this theorem for $S^1$, $S^3$ and $S^7$ since these are the only three that are connected H-spaces (don't forget that $S^0 = \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}$ is an H-space too, but it's not path-connected). You have (let $n \in \{1,3,7\}$): $$H_i(S^n; \mathbb{Q}) = \begin{cases} \mathbb{Q} & i = 0,n; \\ 0 & \text{otherwise.} \end{cases}$$

The theorem tells you that this is a free graded-commutative algebra on some graded vector space $V$. Clearly you must have a generator $e \in V_n$ of degree $V$ corresponding to the fundamental class, it cannot be written as a product of lower-degree elements. Since $n$ is odd, $e^2 = 0$. There is nothing else in the homology, so you get that $V$ is one-dimensional spanned by an element of degree $n$, and thus for $n \in \{1,3,7\}$: $$\pi_i(S^n) \otimes \mathbb{Q} = \begin{cases} \mathbb{Q} & i = n; \\ 0 & \text{otherwise.} \end{cases}$$

I don't know what the author of the problem had in mind precisely, but note that you can't directly apply the theorem to even-dimensional spheres in any case. Indeed if $H_*(S^{2n})$ were a free graded-commutative algebra, there would have to be a generator $e$ in degree $2n$ corresponding to the fundamental class. But then $e^2 \in H_{4n}(S^{2n})$ would be a nonzero element... Which is not possible. For odd-dimensional spheres you get the same result as for the ones that are H-spaces ($\pi_{2n+1}(S^{2n+1}) \otimes \mathbb{Q} = \mathbb{Q}$ and zero otherwise).

  • $\begingroup$ Yes, thank you. I had figured out how to deduce the cases $n\in\{1,3,7\}$ from the Milnor-Moore theorem but it's a mystery to me how one would use this theorem for the case $n\notin \{1,3,7\}$. $\endgroup$ – iwriteonbananas Jan 7 '17 at 15:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.