3
$\begingroup$

Let's say that a linear order is $\omega_1$-short if it has no uncountable well-ordered or reverse well-ordered subset. For instance, linear orders satisfying Suslin's condition in his hypothesis are $\omega_1$-short. There are $\omega_1$-short linear orders which do not satisfy the countable chain condition.

Is there a $\omega_1$-short linear order in which every $\omega_1$-short linear order embeds?

Any $\omega_1$-short linear order embeds in the complete lexicographically ordered binary tree $2^{<\omega_1}$ (which can be ssen as a subfield of the ordered Field of surreals), but $2^{<\omega_1}$ is not $\omega_1$-short. I do not think that any of the $2^{<\alpha},\alpha < \omega_1$ qualify, even though they are $\omega_1$-short, but I don't have a proof. I actually don't know yet if $2^{<\alpha+1}$ can embed in $2^{< \alpha}$ for some values of $\alpha < \omega_1$.

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

The answer is no. See Corollary 5 in

Their argument is as follows: given an arbitrary linear order $L$, one can consider the set $\sigma L$ of all well ordered subsets of $L$ with end extension as a partial order. This partial order is extended to a linear order by the lexicographic ordering. It is easy to see that if $L$ is $\omega_1$-short then $\sigma L$ must be $\omega_1$-short as well.

However $\sigma L$ never embeds into $L$ (so $L$ is not universal). Indeed, if $f:\sigma L\to L$ is an order preserving embedding then define $s(\alpha)=f(s|\alpha)$ by induction on $\alpha \in ORD$ (taking unions at limit steps). If $\alpha<\beta$ then $s|\beta$ is an end extension of $s|\alpha$ so $s(\alpha)=f(s|\alpha)<f(s|\beta)=s(\beta)$. I.e. $s:\mathrm{ORD}\to L$ is injective which is clearly impossible.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ This is a very nice argument (I like it when $Ord$ tries to inject inself into some sets); thank you for the reference as well. $\endgroup$ – nombre Feb 7 '17 at 10:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.