7
$\begingroup$

Please forgive the long setup but I think it is relevant to my question.

I am a third year Electrical Engineering student (before dismissing me a an engineer please read the rest of the question) and I am planning on doing graduate studies in Control Theory. I find it really brings together pure math and some sort of distant application which is enough for me. As such I've taken the usual engineering math courses (Calculus, Linear Algebra, Complex Analysis, Dynamical Systems, a whole ton of Fourier analysis, PDEs, Probabilities and such) where they proceeded to completely disregard any rigor. The only thing close to rigorous math that I actually did was in our Algorithms course which was fascinating (P=NP, Graphs, etc) and actually satisfyingly rigorous.

Anyways, I am now at a point where I want to strengthen my actual math knowledge and especially work towards a really good knowledge of Differential Geometry, Complex Analysis and Topology. As such I began studying the basics: real analysis with Chapman Pugh which I am really enjoying. However I would have appreciated some input on what you think is the best way to proceed from here.

My plan was next to do Topology with Munkres, Abstract Algebra with Dummit (perhaps not everything but at the very least a good coverage of group theory) and sometime after Smooth Manifolds by Lee and Papa Rudin. What do you think?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ As a control engineer who has done his studies up to PhD, I recommend you not to mix up your college studies. This way you will end up knowing a little of both and not being able to use either of them. It is always good to focus on one thing until you are done with it, and then pursue another thing $\endgroup$ – polfosol Dec 1 '16 at 21:24
4
$\begingroup$

I have a background in EE and I am studying control theory, therefore I have some different insight than someone from pure or applied mathematics.

Let me preface my answer with a warning: Most people are turned on by the IDEA of studying complicated subjects, but these are the same people who are turned off actually having to do the work.

You see these questions on Mathstackexchange all the time, people listing dozens of books each 700 pages long and asking whether if it is feasible to go through them during the course of their undergrad. I think engineering students in general are more prone to burn out while studying if the material is not tethered to applications.

To gain a basic background in control theory for application or research here are the courses that are must:

  1. The basics: Linear algebra, complex analysis, multivariable calculus, ODE
  2. Frequency domain control theory, and State Space control theory
  3. Nonlinear dynamical system
  4. Linear operator theory

These are the prerequisites that most control books will contain or teach you such as one by Sontag, Dullerud, Sastry, Khalil, Vidyasagar.

To do more advanced work you need a course on (usually in grad school):

  1. Optimization
  2. Real analysis and topology
  3. Classical mechanics
  4. Probability and random processes

These will cover optimal control, control of time varying systems, robotics and stochastic control and coming up with new results. There are other fields that I haven't even mentioned and requires (more) sophisticated tools like finite automaton, machine learning, etc.

Now the question is which field do you want to apply your control in. This opens to the door to biology, quantum mechanics, circuit theory, signal and image processing

Hope this helps.

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

From a purely mathematical perspective, I think taking courses (with the Math department at your university, not the engineering department) in Real Analysis, Complex Analysis, Functional Analysis, Abstract Algebra, Algebraic Topology, Smooth Manifolds, Lie Theory, Dynamical Systems and Differential Geometry should really set you up for the mathematics to do graduate level work in control theory.

Admittedly that is a lot of courses, but since you have already taken some, you could probably skip the first three. As for the rest, you can take some of them now and the others in your first year of graduate school.

Of course there also controls courses in Linear Systems, Non-linear and Adaptive Control, Robust Control, Geometric Control, etc. but for those, the offerings might differ from university to university, and it really depends on what area of control theory you want to work in.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.