12
$\begingroup$

Suppose there is a nonempty set $A_n^i$ that is indexed over $\omega$, the natural numbers. Can I say the following is true?

$$\bigcup_{i \in \omega} \left\{\bigcap_{n\in \omega} A_n^i\right\} = \bigcap_{n\in \omega}\left\{ \bigcup_{i \in \omega} A_n^i\right\}$$

Can anyone give me some idea as to whether nor not I would be able to interchange the union and intersection?

$\endgroup$
1

2 Answers 2

19
$\begingroup$

Note that

$$x\in\bigcup_{i\in\omega}\bigcap_{n\in\omega}A_n^i$$

iff $\exists i\in\omega\,\forall n\in\omega\,(x\in A_n^i)$, while

$$x\in\bigcap_{n\in\omega}\bigcup_{i\in\omega}A_n^i$$

iff $\forall n\in\omega\,\exists i\in\omega\,(x\in A_n^i)$; the latter condition is on the face of it easier to satisfy, so you should look for an example in which

$$\bigcup_{i\in\omega}\bigcap_{n\in\omega}A_n^i\subsetneqq\bigcap_{n\in\omega}\bigcup_{i\in\omega}A_n^i\;.$$

Specifically, we might try to construct the sets $A_n^i$ so that there is some element $a\in A_n^n$ for all $n\in\omega$, which will ensure that

$$a\in\bigcap_{n\in\omega}\bigcup_{i\in\omega}A_n^i\;,$$

but so that there is no $i\in\omega$ such that $a\in A_n^i$ for all $n\in\omega$. This is easy: for each $i\in\omega$ make sure that $a\in A_n^i$ iff $n=i$. Thus, we can let

$$A_n^i=\begin{cases} \{a\},&\text{if }n=i\\ \varnothing,&\text{otherwise}\;. \end{cases}$$

Then

$$\bigcup_{i\in\omega}\bigcap_{n\in\omega}A_n^i=\bigcup_{n\in\omega}\varnothing=\varnothing\;,$$

but

$$\bigcap_{n\in\omega}\bigcup_{i\in\omega}A_n^i=\bigcap_{n\in\omega}\{a\}=\{a\}\;.$$

$\endgroup$
2
  • $\begingroup$ That makes perfect sense. Thank you! $\endgroup$
    – Maria
    Commented Oct 31, 2016 at 16:47
  • $\begingroup$ @Maria: You’re welcome! $\endgroup$ Commented Oct 31, 2016 at 16:47
12
$\begingroup$

This is not possible in general. Even for finite unions and intersections you can have $$ (A_1\cap A_2)\cup(B_1\cap B_2)\subsetneqq(A_1\cup B_1)\cap(A_2\cup B_2). $$ Take for example $A_2=A_1^c$ (the complement in $X\neq\emptyset$) and $B_1=A_2,\;B_2=A_1$; then $$ A_1\cap A_2=B_1\cap B_2=\emptyset,\qquad A_1\cup B_1=A_2\cup B_2=X. $$

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .