So it states in Guillemin and Pollack:

Let $x_1, \ldots x_4$ be points in general position $R^3$ (that is they all don't lie in a plane.) Let $q_1, \ldots, q_4$ be electric charges placed at these points. The potential function of the resulting electric field is: $$V_q = \frac{q_1}{r_1} + \ldots + \frac{q_4}{r_4}$$ where $r_i = |x - x_i|$. The critical points of $V_q$ are called the equilibrium points of the electric field, and an equilibrium point is non-degenerate if the critical point is. Prove that for "almost every" $q$ the equilibrium points of $V_q$ are non-degenerate and finite in number.

They provide the hint to show that "the map: $R^3 - \{x_1, x_2, x_3, x_4\} \to R^4$ with coordinates $r_1$, $r_2$, $r_3$, r_4". I am somewhat sure that this means:

\begin{align} r_1 &= \frac{q_1}{|x - x_1|} \\ r_2 &= \frac{q_2}{|x - x_2|} \\ r_3 &= \frac{q_3}{|x - x_3|} \\ r_4 &= \frac{q_4}{|x - x_4|} \end{align}

Calculating $dV(q)_x$ gives (let $b(x,y,z) = (x-x_1)^2 + (y-x_2)^2 + (z-z_2)^2$):

$$ \begin{bmatrix} q_1(x_1 - x) & q_1(x_1 - y) & q_1(x_1 - z) \\ q_2(x_2 - x) & q_2(x_2 - y) & q_2(x_3 - z) \\ q_3(x_3 - x) & q_3(x_3 - y) & q_3(x_3 - z) \\ q_4(x_4 - x) & q_4(x_4 - y) & q_4(x_4 - z) \end{bmatrix} b(x,y,z)^{-3/2} $$

The matrix is non-zero everywhere (well, on the weird domain) so $dV(q)_x$ must be injective and therefore the map is an immersion. They then say to use Exercise 21, the results of which is:

Let $\phi : X \to R^N$ be an immersion. Then for almost every $a_1, \ldots a_N$, $a_1\phi_1 + \ldots + a_N\phi_N$ is a Morse function.

Using this result we see that $V_q$ is an immersion so almost every point must be $q$ that is in the equilibrium must also be non-degenerate as a property of Morse functions. Any hints, or reasons why is it finite?


I'm going to take a stab (there might still be a problem, if there is please leave a comment and I will try to amend it.)

I was given a hint. Imagine these points are in an infinitely large sphere. For a sufficiently large "zoom out" away from the four points, the charge becomes virtually identical to 1 charge. Clearly, 1 charge is never stable, so we need only consider a "large enough" sphere. Now our parent manifold is compact. Which is great.

The non-degenerate critical points are isolated, combine this with the fact that we are dealing ourselves with a compact set, we can only have finite number of critical points, otherwise such a sequence of points we could choose points infinitely close so that they are not isolated.

Therefore, there cannot exist an infinite number, only a finite.

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.