I'm trying to find possible values for the Diophantine equation: $$ (2a)^2 +b^2=c^{4}a^2d^2 +4d \tag{1}\\ $$ With: $$ \gcd(a,d)=1 \tag{2} $$ Where $a,b,c,d $ all integers $ >0$.

Specifically i'm interested in possible values for $d$.
For instance $d=1$ has solutions because for $d=1$ condition $(2)$ is automatically satisfied for every $a$. But $d=2$ has no solutions (i think, see proof below).
I'm hoping to prove that there are no solutions for $d \neq 1$.

I have two questions:
1) Does anyone know how to determine all possible values for $d$ in equation above?
2) I tried below to prove some statements myself ($d\neq 2,3 \nmid d, 4 \nmid d$ and $a,b,d$ have no common prime divisors $>2$). But i'm not shure they are correct. So if you can verify some of the statements below please let me know.

$(*1) \enspace d \neq 2$ $$ d=2 \implies \text{ everything must be divisible by } 4 \implies\\ a^2 +{{b^2}\over{4}}=c^{4}a^2 +2 \tag{3}\\ $$ $a$ must be odd because of $(2)$. If $c$ is odd then ${{b^2}\over{4}}$ must be even. But then ${{b^2}\over{4}}$ must be divisible by $4$ because it's a perfect square. Then if we take $(3) \pmod 4$ we get the contradiction : $1+0 \equiv 1+2 \pmod 4 $. So assume $c$ is even and ${{b^2}\over{4}}$ is odd.
Rewriting $(3)$ shows that we can then isolate a term that must be divisible by $3$:
${{b^2}\over{4}}=(c^{4}-1)a^2 +2= (c^{2}+1)(c-1)(c+1)a^2 +2 \implies {b^2\over{4}} \equiv 2 \pmod 3$ . Contradiction because $2$ is not in the quadratic residues $\pmod 3$ .

$(*2) \enspace 3 \nmid d$
Also $3$ can not divide $d$ : This would mean: $ 3 \mid (2a)^2 + b^2 \implies 3 \mid a^2 \land 3 \mid b^2 $ (see for example here). This is a contradiction with equation $(2)$.

$(*3) \enspace a,b,d $ 'coprime' for divisors $>2$
From $(1)$ and $(2)$ we see that any prime $p > 2$ that divides $d$ can not divide $a$ and therefore can also not divide $b$ because $d$ divides the right hand side of $(1)$ . So $\gcd(p,b)=1$ for prime $p>2$ with $p \mid d$.
Also a prime $p' > 2$ that divides $a$ can not divide $d$ and therefore can't divide $b$. So $\gcd(p',b)=1$.

$(*4) \enspace 4 \nmid d$
$$ d= \text{ even } \implies a= \text{ odd and everything is divisible by } 4 \implies\\ a^2 +{{b^2}\over{4}}=c^4a^2{{d^{2}}\over{4}} +d \\ a^2 +b'^2=c^4a^2d'^2 +2d' \\ d'= \text{ even } \implies \text{ right side divisible by } 4 \implies \text{ left side two odd squares }\\ \implies 1+1\equiv 0 \pmod 4 \implies \text{ contradiction }\\ $$ We conclude that $4 \nmid d$.


If $p$ is a prime dividing $d$, we need $4 a^2 + b^2 \equiv 0 \mod p$. Since $a$ can't be divisible by $p$, that says $-4$ is a square mod $p$. The primes with this property are $2$ and those $\equiv 1 \mod 4$.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks, i don't yet see how you got to the '-4 is square mod p' yet. Maybe basic stuff, but i'm not well informed on this. I'll think about it $\endgroup$ – Rutger Moody Sep 28 '16 at 20:58
  • $\begingroup$ Since $a$ is invertible mod $p$, there is $c$ such that $b = a c$. Then $4 a^2 + b^2 \equiv 0$ becomes $c^2 \equiv -4$. $\endgroup$ – Robert Israel Sep 28 '16 at 21:40
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks again! I now realise that quadratic reciprocity is sort of an all important theorem in these cases. I saw it come by earlier but didn't think it mattered. This certainly gives extra information on the structure. I still have hope i can reduce the possibilities further (that is: i don't think p=1 mod4 automatically means it must have solutions) I'll look into it. $\endgroup$ – Rutger Moody Sep 29 '16 at 8:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.