This is an exercise for the book Abstract Algebra by Dummit and Foote (pg. 530):

Let $F$ be a field of characteristic $\neq2$ . Let $a,b\in F$ with $b$ not a square in $F$. Prove $\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}=\sqrt{m}+\sqrt{n}$ for some $m,n\in F$ iff $a^{2}-b$ is a square in $F$.

I am having problem proving this claim, I tried to assume $\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}=\sqrt{m}+\sqrt{n}$ and I naturally squared both sides, to try and get $a^{2}$ I squared both sides again and then reduced $2b$ from both sides and rearranged to get $$a^{2}-b=(m+n+2\sqrt{mn})^{2}-2\sqrt{b}(a+\sqrt{b})$$ but I don't see how I can use it.

Can someone please help me prove this claim ?

  • $\begingroup$ You have "not a square" in the title but your question asks the opposite. Is this intentional? $\endgroup$ – Alex R. Sep 9 '12 at 20:01
  • $\begingroup$ @Sam - No, that was a typo. thanks for pointing this out to me! $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 20:03
  • $\begingroup$ Not sure if this will help, but maybe use $$a^2-b = (a+\sqrt{b})(a-\sqrt{b}) = x(x-2\sqrt{b})$$ for $x = m+n+2\sqrt{mn}$? $\endgroup$ – gt6989b Sep 9 '12 at 20:16

$$\sqrt{a+\sqrt b}=\sqrt m + \sqrt n \Rightarrow a+\sqrt b = m+n+2\sqrt{mn}$$ Since $\phi(\alpha+\beta\sqrt b)=\alpha-\beta\sqrt b$ for $\alpha,\beta\in F$ defines an automorphism $\phi\colon F[\sqrt b]\to F[\sqrt b]$ that leaves $F$ fixed, we have that $\phi(\sqrt{mn})= \pm\sqrt{mn}$ because $\phi$ maps the polynomial $X^2-mn$ to itself and can at most interchange its roots. Thus we additionally get $a-\sqrt b=\phi(a+\sqrt b)=\phi(m+n+2\sqrt{mn})$, i.e. $$a-\sqrt b=m+n\pm2\sqrt{mn}.$$ Since $\sqrt b\ne -\sqrt b$ (characteristic $\ne 2$), the left hand sides differ, hence so do the right hand soides, hence "$\pm$" is really "$-$". By adding and subtracting these equations we find that $a=m+n$ and $\sqrt b =2\sqrt{mn}$. Hence $m,n$ are roots of $0=X^2-(m+n)X+mn=X^2-a X+\frac b4$ and can be found as $$\frac{a\pm\sqrt{a^2-b}}2$$ More precisely:

  • If $a^2-b$ is a square, this actually produces $m,n\in F$ with the property that $(\sqrt m +\sqrt n)^2=a+\sqrt b$, i.e. $\sqrt m + \sqrt n$ is a root of $X^2-(a+\sqrt b)$ as desired.
  • If $a^2-b$ is not a square, no solutions for $m,n$ exist in $F$.
  • $\begingroup$ Can you please explain "It can only map $\sqrt{mn}\mapsto \pm\sqrt{mn}$." ? I don't understand why $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 20:50
  • $\begingroup$ $\sqrt{mn}$ is a root of $X^2-mn\in F[X]$. Every automorphism of $F[\sqrt b]$ over $F$ leaves $F$ and hence this polynomial fixed. It can at most interchange the roots, which means flip sign for square roots. $\endgroup$ – Hagen von Eitzen Sep 9 '12 at 20:53
  • $\begingroup$ I don't think that every automorphism of $F[\sqrt{b}]$ leaves $F$. for example take $F=\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2})$ and $b=3$ then you know that there is an automorphism of $F[\sqrt{b}]$ that takes $\sqrt{2}$ to $-\sqrt{2}$ $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 20:56
  • $\begingroup$ Yes. But every automorphism of $F[\sqrt b]$ over $F$. In fact, in this simple case it can be written explicitly as $\phi(\alpha +\beta\sqrt b)=\alpha-\beta\sqrt b$ for $\alpha,\beta\in F$. $\endgroup$ – Hagen von Eitzen Sep 9 '12 at 21:02
  • $\begingroup$ sorry I didn't see it's over $F$. How do we get the equality after "Thus we additionally get" ? I know that the LHS it mapped to the RHS but that does not mean their equal... $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 21:05

$$\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}} = \sqrt{m} + \sqrt{n}$$ $$a+\sqrt{b} = m+n+2\sqrt{mn}$$ Thus $a = m+n$ and $b = 4mn$ as $b$ is not a square . Finally, $$a^2 -b = m^2 + 2mn + n^2 -4mn = (m-n)^2$$.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I don't understand your "Thus"...maybe $\sqrt{b}=n+2\sqrt{mn}$.. $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 20:47
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ Say $\sqrt{b} = c + 2\sqrt{mn}$. Note that $a,b,m,n, (c=m+n-a) \in F$ but $\sqrt{mn}, \sqrt{b} \notin F$. After squaring you get $b = c^2 + 4mn + 4c\sqrt{mn}$ where $\text{rhs} \notin F$. $\endgroup$ – Karolis Juodelė Sep 9 '12 at 20:58
  • $\begingroup$ Why $\sqrt{mn}\not\in F$ ? what if $m=n=2$ ? $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 21:00
  • $\begingroup$ Then also $a+\sqrt{b} \in F$ (follows from my second equation), which we know not to be the case. $\endgroup$ – Karolis Juodelė Sep 10 '12 at 3:58

Hint $\rm\,\ \left[\sqrt{a+\sqrt b}\,=\,\sqrt m + \sqrt n\right]^2\! \Rightarrow\: a+\sqrt b \,=\, m\!+\!n+2\sqrt{mn}\in F[\sqrt{b}].\:$ Thus, taking "norms" $\rm\:a^2 - b\, =\, (m+n)^2 - 4mn = (m-n)^2,\:$ where norm = constant term of minimal polynomial.

  • $\begingroup$ How did you calculate those norms ? $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 22:55
  • $\begingroup$ @Belgi Compare their monic minimal polynomials $\rm\: (x-\alpha)(x-\alpha') = x^2 - (\alpha+\alpha')\, x + \alpha\alpha'.$ $\endgroup$ – Bill Dubuque Sep 9 '12 at 23:09
  • $\begingroup$ Should I find the minimal polynomial of $a+\sqrt{b}$ to calculate its norm ? $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 23:12
  • $\begingroup$ @Belgi The monic minimal polynomial is unique (else subtracting two different ones gives a smaller deg poly, contra min). Thus both sides have the same monic minimal polynomial, so the same constant coefficient - which is the (formal) norm. $\endgroup$ – Bill Dubuque Sep 9 '12 at 23:17
  • $\begingroup$ I know that this polynomial is unique, but I don't understand what you calculated to get the quality after the word - " "norms" " $\endgroup$ – Belgi Sep 9 '12 at 23:19

Let $F$ be a field of charcteristic different from 2. Let $a$ and $b$ be elements of the field $F$ with $b$ not a square in F. Prove that a necessary and sufficient condition for $\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}={\sqrt{m}+\sqrt{n}}$ for $m,n\in F$ is that $a^2-b$ is a square in $F.$

Solution. $\Rightarrow:$ Suppose that $a^2-b$ is a square in $F$. Then $\sqrt{a^2-b}\in F.$ Let $$m= \frac{a+\sqrt{a^2-b}}{2}$$ and $$n= \frac{a-\sqrt{a^2-b}}{2}.$$ Then $n,m\in F$ because $\textrm{char}\, F\neq 0.$

$\Leftarrow:$ Now $$m =\frac{a+\sqrt{a^2-b}}{2} = \frac{(a+\sqrt{b})+2\sqrt{a^2-b}+(a-\sqrt{b})}{4} = \left( \frac{\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}+\sqrt{a-\sqrt{b}}}{2} \right)^2,$$ this means that $$\sqrt{m}=\frac{\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}+\sqrt{a-\sqrt{b}}}{2}.$$

Also $$n =\frac{a-\sqrt{a^2-b}}{2} = \frac{(a+\sqrt{b})-2\sqrt{a^2-b}+(a-\sqrt{b})}{4} = \left( \frac{\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}-\sqrt{a-\sqrt{b}}}{2} \right)^2,$$ this means that $$\sqrt{n}=\frac{\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}-\sqrt{a-\sqrt{b}}}{2}.$$

Thus $$\sqrt{m}+\sqrt{n} =\frac{\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}+\sqrt{a-\sqrt{b}}}{2}+\frac{\sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}-\sqrt{a-\sqrt{b}}}{2} = \sqrt{a+\sqrt{b}}.$$


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.