3
$\begingroup$

New to Linear Algebra and trying to get decent at proofs. Any help is appreciated.

Is this a valid way to prove the Cancellation Law of Multiplication? I've only seen it done some alternative way that doesn't make much intuitive sense to me.

Given: For all real numbers $x,y,k$ where $k\neq 0$ .

If $kx = ky$, then $x = y $

*First, $ky, kx$ are also real numbers by the Closure property of Multiplication

$kx = ky$ : Implication

$k(1/k)x = k(1/k)y $: Substitution

$(k(1/k))x = (k(1/k))y $: Associative Property of Multiplication

$(1)x = (1)y$ : Multiplicative Inverse

$x = y$ : Multiplicative Identity

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Not sure that the second step is "substitution". Placing the 1/k in the middle rather than the end makes me want to see an reasoning by comutivity. Seems good though. $\endgroup$ – fleablood Sep 4 '16 at 0:40
1
$\begingroup$

I could be wrong but I think the second step is rushed.

I'd do something like.

$\frac 1k(kx )= \frac 1k(kx )$: identity;binary operation

$\frac1k (kx)=\frac 1k (ky)$:substitution

But maybe I don't understand your second line. The rest is perfect.

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

You have the right idea for the proof. I'd change some of the wording.

$kx = ky$ : Hypothesis (not Implication)

In the next line you have implicitly used the commutativity of multiplication. Instead write

$(1/k)(kx) = (1/k)(ky) $: Multiply both sides by the $1/k$, which exists because we've assumed $k \ne 0$.

$((1/k)k)x = ( (1/k)k)y $: Associative Property of Multiplication

The rest is fine as is

$(1)x = (1)y$ : Multiplicative Inverse

$x = y$ : Multiplicative Identity

This theorem and its proof really have nothing to do with linear algebra - the right context is the real number system (more abstractly, a field) although you encountered it in a linear algebra course, which is often where students first have to write careful proofs.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.