Let $G$ be a finite group, and let $P_1, ..., P_r$ be its nontrivial Sylow subgroups. Assume all $P_i$ are normal in $G$.

I need to prove that $(P_1...P_{r-1}) \cap P_r = \{ e \}$.

I know that $P_1...P_{r-1}$ is a normal subgroup of $G$( since all $P_i$ are normal ). But I don't know what is its order $|P_1...P_{r-1}|$, though, if it's important( could use Lagrange's theorem ).

I also know the case for $r = 3$. By Second Isomorphism Theorem we have

$|P_1P_2| = \frac{|P_1||P_2|}{|P_1 \cap P_2|} = |P_1||P_2| = p^{m_1}_1p^{m_2}_2$ Since $\gcd(|P_1P_2|,|P_3|) = 1$, then $P_1P_2 \cap P_3 = \{ e \}$.


If each Sylow subgroup is normal, then there is a unique Sylow subgroup for each prime dividing the order of the group. Every element of $P_r$ will have order a power of some prime $p_r$, while each other $P_i$ contains only elements of order relatively prime to $p_r$.

More formally, for $x \in (P_1\dotsb P_{r-1})\cap P_r$, we must have that $x$ has order $p_r^k$ because it is in $P_r$ and also have order $p_1^{k_1}\dotsb p_{r-1}^{k_{r-1}}$ because it is in $P_1\dotsb P_{r-1}$ where $\gcd(p_r,p_1\dotsb p_{r-1}) = 1$. This can only be the case where $k = k_1 = \dotsb = k_{r-1} = 0$, so $x$ has order $0$ and must be the identity.

  • $\begingroup$ So, let $g_i \in P_i$. Assume $g_1...g_{r-1} = g_r$. $|g_r|$ divides $|P_r| = p^{m_r}_r$, so $|g_r| = p^n_r n \leq m_r$. On the other hand, $|g_1...g_{r-1}|$ divides $lcm(|g_1|, ..., |g_{r-1}|) = p^n_1_1...p^{n_{r-1}}_{r-1}$. Since $\gcd(p^n_r, p^n_1_1...p^{n_{r-1}}_{r-1}) = 1, |g_r| = |g_1...g_{r-1}| = 1$, and $g = g_1...g_{r-1} = e$. Right? $\endgroup$ – Jxt921 Aug 21 '16 at 1:15
  • $\begingroup$ @Jxt921, yeah, I think it could be worded better, but you have the correct idea now. $\endgroup$ – Mike Pierce Aug 21 '16 at 2:00

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.