# What values gives the minimum area of the ellipse?

If the ellipse $\dfrac{x^2}{A}+\dfrac{y^2}{B}=1$ is to enclose the circle $x^2+y^2=2y$, what values of $A,B>0$ minimize the area of the ellipse?

So far I've put the circle equation into the standard form: $x^2+(y-1)^2=1$, and I know that $A,B$ represents the length of semi-major and semi-minor axis. I'm not sure how to make sure the circle is enclosed in the ellipse.

• Shouldn't $A$ be equal to $a^2$ and $B$ equal to $b^2$ ? Than $\sqrt{A}$ and $\sqrt{B}$ would represent the length of the semi-major and semi-minor axis. – Curious Aug 9 '16 at 16:23

## 3 Answers

We require the two conics to touch each other. Eliminating $x^2$ leads to the quadratic equation $$(A-B)y^2+2By-AB=0$$

Assuming $A\neq B$, applying the condition that the discriminant is zero leads to the equation $$A^2-AB+B=0$$

We now need to minimize the area $\Delta=\pi\sqrt{AB}$.

Therefore we can differentiate $$\Delta^2=\pi^2AB=\pi^2\frac{A^3}{A-1}$$

Setting the derivative to zero will give $$A=\frac 32, B=\frac 92$$

It is readily seen that this will provide the minimum area since there is no maximum. Therefore the semiaxes are $$\sqrt{A}=\sqrt{\frac 32}, \sqrt{B}=\frac{3}{\sqrt{2}}$$

The minimum ellipse area is then $$\frac{3\sqrt{3}}{2}\pi$$

• How did you eliminate x squared? I've been playing around with both equations but I get to a point where I can't factor anything. – Jack A Mar 19 '19 at 17:37

The problem has already been solved. If I put a second circle $$x^2+(y+1)^2=1$$ in the diagram, the problem is:

What is the ellipse of smallest area that can enclose two non-overlapping unit circles?

On Erich Friedman's Packing Centre the following answer by James Buddenhagen is given: The ellipse that solves both the problem above and the original question has semi-major axis $$\frac{3}{\sqrt2}$$, semi-minor axis $$\sqrt\frac32$$ and area $$\frac{3\sqrt3\pi}2$$.

• A proof would be nice. The link does not have one. – marty cohen Aug 9 '16 at 20:29
• @martycohen Is given by Quinn above. – Parcly Taxel Aug 10 '16 at 4:26
• The link does not have a proof. – marty cohen Aug 10 '16 at 4:48
• I meant Quinn's proof, on this same page! – Parcly Taxel Aug 10 '16 at 4:49

From the equation $x^2+(y-1)^2=1$, the circle has center $(0, 1)$ and radius $1$. Therefore the points on it with minimum and maximum $x$ and $y$ values are $(0, 0), (1, 1), (0, 2), (-1, 1)$.

Since the ellipse has center at the origin, it has to have a max $y$ value of at least $2$ and a max $x$ value of at least $1$.

For the equation $\dfrac{x^2}{A}+\dfrac{y^2}{B}=1$, this means that $A \ge 1$ and $B \ge 4 = 2^2$.

However, if the ellipse has greater curvature at the top than the circle, it will intersect the circle. The radius of curvature of the ellipse with $A=1, B=4$ is $\frac{a}{b} =\frac14$, which is smaller than that of the circle, which is $1$. So, we have to modify the values of $A$ and $B$ so that the ellipse is tangent to the circle.

An easy way to do this is to make the ellipse a circle of radius $2$, so the values are $A=B=4$.

Another possibility is to make $A$ slightly larger and $B$ larger so that the ellipse is tangent to the circle at two points. I think that, for any $A> 1$, the value of $B$ that makes this happen could be determined, but I do not feel like working this out. The desired answer would be the one that minimizes $AB$.