From Royden and Fitzpatrick's Real Analysis, Fourth Edition (Chapter 1, Problem 48):

Let $f$ be the function defined by $$ f(x) = \begin{cases} x & \text{if $x$ is irrational} \\ p \cdot \sin \frac{1}{q} & \text{if $x = \frac{p}{q}$ in lowest terms} \end{cases} $$ At what points is $f$ continuous?

This function is similar to the one considered here.

I was able to show that $f$ is continuous at $0$ and not continuous at any non-zero rational number. I believe $f$ is continuous on the irrationals, but am having trouble proving this conjecture. My idea was to pick a small enough neighborhood around $x$ that the only rationals in the neighborhood would have $q$ so large that $\left|1 - q \sin \frac{1}{q}\right|$ was arbitrarily small. The rest of the proof will follow nicely if I can show such a neighborhood exists, but I am having trouble constructing it.

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ What is $\lim_{h\rightarrow0}{\sin h\over h}$? $\endgroup$ – David Mitra Jul 20 '16 at 22:29
  • $\begingroup$ @DavidMitra I believe the limit is 1, but I don't quite see how this helps. $\endgroup$ – David Jul 20 '16 at 22:54
  • $\begingroup$ If $x$ is irrational, then, given $N$, you can find an open interval $O$ containing $x$ so that any rational in $O$ in lowest terms has denominator exceeding $N$. This, and the limit above, gives you what you want ($q\sin(1/q) = \sin(1/q)/(1/q)$ ). $\endgroup$ – David Mitra Jul 20 '16 at 23:03
  • $\begingroup$ @DavidMitra Right I guess my question was how to explicitly construct such an open interval. Can I just use the continued fraction expansion of $x$? $\endgroup$ – David Jul 20 '16 at 23:21

Let us first show that $f$ is continuous at 0. By construction, $f(0) = 0$. Now pick any $\epsilon > 0$. Since $\lim_{n \to \infty} n \sin \dfrac{1}{n} = 1$, there exists an index $N$ such that $$ n \sin \dfrac{1}{n} < 1+\epsilon $$ for all $n \geq N$. Let $\delta = \min\left\{\dfrac{1}{N},\dfrac{\epsilon}{1+\epsilon}\right\}$. For any non-zero rational number $x = \dfrac{p}{q}$, where $\dfrac{p}{q}$ is in lowest terms, we have \begin{align*} \left|x\right| = \left|\frac{p}{q}\right| < \delta \qquad &\Rightarrow \qquad \frac{1}{\delta} \leq \frac{|p|}{\delta} < |q| \\ &\Rightarrow \qquad N \leq |q| \\ &\Rightarrow \qquad \left|q\right| \cdot \left|\sin \frac{1}{q}\right| < 1 + \epsilon \\ &\Rightarrow \qquad |f(x)| = \left|p \cdot \sin \frac{1}{q}\right| \leq \delta \cdot \left|q\right| \cdot \left|\sin \frac{1}{q}\right| < \delta \cdot (1 + \epsilon) \leq \epsilon \end{align*} If $x$ is irrational, then $$ |x| < \delta \qquad \Rightarrow \qquad |f(x)| = |x| < \epsilon $$ Thus $|x - 0| < \delta$ implies $|f(x) - 0| < \epsilon$, so $f(x)$ is continuous at zero.

Let us now show that $f$ is discontinuous at all non-zero rational numbers. Let $x = \dfrac{p}{q}$ be a non-zero rational number and consider the sequence $$ x_n = \frac{p}{q} \cdot \frac{(p\cdot q + 1)^n +q}{(p\cdot q + 1)^n} =: \frac{p_n}{q_n} $$ By construction, $p_n$ and $q_n$ are relatively prime and $\lim_{n\to \infty} x_n = x$. We therefore have $$ \lim_{n\to \infty} f(x_n) = \lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{p_n}{q_n} \cdot q_n \cdot \sin \frac{1}{q_n} = \left(\lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{p_n}{q_n}\right) \cdot \left( \lim_{n \to \infty} q_n \cdot \sin \frac{1}{q_n}\right) = \frac{p}{q} $$ However $$ f(x) = p \sin \frac{1}{q} \neq \frac{p}{q} $$ because the left-hand side is an irrational number for all integers $q$. Since $\lim_{n\to \infty} x_n = x$ but $\lim_{n\to \infty} f(x_n) \neq f(x)$, $f$ is not continuous at $x$.

Lastly, we can also show that $f$ is continuous at all irrational numbers. Let $x$ be an irrational number and fix $\epsilon > 0$. Let $x = [a_0; a_1, a_2, \cdots]$ denote the continued fraction expansion of $x$ and define the sequences \begin{align*} h_n = a_n h_{n-1} + h_{n-1} \qquad h_{-1} = 1 \qquad h_{-2} = 0 \\ k_n = a_n k_{n-1} + k_{n-1} \qquad h_{-1} = 0 \qquad h_{-2} = 1 \end{align*} Since the $a_n \geq 1$ for all $n \geq 1$, $k_n \to \infty$. It is possible to show $\left\{\dfrac{h_n}{k_n}\right\} \to x$ and $$ \left|x - \frac{h_n}{k_n}\right| < \left|x - \frac{p}{q}\right| $$ for any rational $\dfrac{p}{q}$ satisfying $0 < q < k_n$, This means we can find an index $N$ such that \begin{gather*} \left|x - \frac{h_N}{k_N}\right| < \frac{\epsilon \cdot |x|}{\epsilon + 2 \cdot |x|} \end{gather*} and $$ \left|1 - n \cdot \sin \frac{1}{n}\right| < \frac{\epsilon}{2 \cdot |x|} $$ for all $n \geq k_N$. Let $\delta = \left|x -\dfrac{h_N}{k_N}\right|$. Then for any rational $\dfrac{p}{q}$ satisfying $\left|x - \dfrac{p}{q}\right| < \delta$, we must have $q \geq k_N$. But this implies \begin{align*} \left|x - p \cdot \sin \frac{1}{q}\right| &\leq \left|x - \frac{p}{q}\right| + \left| \frac{p}{q}\right| \left| 1 - q \cdot \sin \frac{1}{q}\right| \\[8pt] &\leq \left|x - \frac{p}{q}\right|\left(1 +\left| 1 - q \cdot \sin \frac{1}{q}\right|\right) + \left|x\right| \left| 1 - q \cdot \sin \frac{1}{q}\right|\\ &< \epsilon \end{align*} For any irrational $x'$ satisfying $|x' - x| < \delta$, we have $|x' - x| < \epsilon$ because $\delta < \epsilon$. Thus $|x' - x| < \delta$ implies $|f(x') - f(x)| < \epsilon$, so $f$ is continuous at $x$.

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.